Ep 97 – Ideology… and whatnot
Episode 97: Ideology and Whatnot
(Knock on door)
Speaker 1: Knock knock.
Speaker 2: Who's there?
Speaker 1: Ideology.
Theme Voiceover: This is Infants on Thrones. Philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the quorum.
Introduction: A Disclaimer on Ideology
Glenn Ostlund: So, today's episode comes from one of those recordings where you just turn on the mic and see what happens. So I'm going to go ahead and be upfront with a certain disclaimer that this episode isn't nearly as focused around a particular topic as many of our other episodes.
However, you know, as we wandered from topic to topic—from philanthropy or the lack thereof as a post-Mormon, to our experiences growing up in a big Mormon family, to birth order, to sex, to the atonement, to parenting—I started to see the topics cluster around a general theme, which was in my mind: ideology. Particularly, how subscribing to the Mormon ideology influenced our upbringing, and how unsubscribing to that Mormon ideology is influencing our adulthood and shaping our future.
So there you go. Be warned: it's a little scattered. But in the words of that immortal bard Charles Wright: "It's not what you look like when you're doing what you're doing; it's what you're doing when you're doing what you look like you're doing. Express yourself."
Wait, what? You know what? Never mind. Anyway, I hope you enjoy it. Here you go.
Cynicism, Philanthropy, and Post-Mormon Apathy
Brother Jake: As I've left the church, I've become extremely skeptical and critical of ideology. But at the same time, you know, with that loss of any subscription to ideology in general—cuz my wife is, you know, a liberal Democrat, and that's kind of an ideology that she really taps into and that she's very connected to.
Bob Caswell: I like it.
Brother Jake: Right, and it's cool, and she's always been that way, even in the church in Utah Valley. Growing up in Utah Valley, she's always been that way. But I don't know, me—I felt that way for a little while, but then I've kind of come to the point where I'm just kind of more of an independent in a lot of ways.
And the thing is, when I've become as disillusioned as I've become with ideology, because I've seen what kind of ugly things you can get wrapped into when you subscribe to an entire ideology, at the same time, I've become pretty flaccid in terms of actually helping, actually volunteering for things, or becoming motivated to go knock doors or do something about something that I really feel strongly about.
So I guess I'm having a hard time renegotiating that cynicism that I feel—that cynical skepticism that I fostered and that's kind of always in the back of my mind. It's kind of like, "Well, you know, fucking Red Cross buys Lamborghinis with your money, so don't do anything," you know what I mean? And it seems really—
Bob Caswell: What percentage really goes to the people, yeah.
Brother Jake: Right. What percentage really goes to the people? And it seems like kind of a lazy cop-out, but I don't really know how to feel differently about it.
Bob Caswell: In the same way, I identify myself as a left-leaning independent, because I have the same chip on my shoulder: like, never again will I subscribe to some organization who dictates what my belief system is. And therefore, I conveniently also don't have to give money or time or energy to anything or anyone.
Brother Jake: Right. Right, yeah, exactly, exactly!
Glenn Ostlund: And isn't that nice?
Bob Caswell: Yeah, I feel like an asshole a little bit, cuz—
Glenn Ostlund: You know why?
Bob Caswell: Why?
Glenn Ostlund: Cuz neither of you have kids.
Bob Caswell: Explain. Elaborate.
Glenn Ostlund: Once you have kids, that's where your money goes. That's, I mean, for me, that's where my philanthropic efforts go—to raising my kids and supporting their school activities and sports and things like that. You know, the expendable income that you have to be able to donate to a charity, it is reduced.
Bob Caswell: I thought you were going to take it a different direction. That's actually a fascinating concept, because that's the best of both worlds in a way. I mean, of course, having children is a huge commitment and kills your free time and all that stuff, but it also sounds great as a way to channel energy that's way better than on yourself playing computer games more.
Glenn Ostlund: I still play computer games! But my point is that I don't feel that guilt like I'm not giving 10% to the church, you know, or to humanitarian causes. I feel like my philanthropy, my humanitarian efforts, are going towards making my children good people—like good citizens and good neighbors and good friends. That's my project, and it's very hands-on.
Bob Caswell: Right, and that's admirable, because I would imagine that that would be the first area that I would invest in, too, if I were in that position with a child or children. But not being in that position, it does make me wonder what to do other than be an armchair critic of everything, cuz that's the most fun, but it doesn't really produce anything, right?
Brother Jake: You get a couple of podcasts out of it. But you're just some asshole. Literally your entire identity is just some asshole that said one thing about one thing; like, you don't matter, you know?
Bob Caswell: It's not like I just want to matter. I don't want to have kids so that they can validate my own insecurities. But yeah, how the hell do Mormons do it? My brother has five kids and he's in the stake presidency. I don't even understand how that's even fucking possible.
Brother Jake: Because the time you're spending when you're in the stake presidency—that's like 15 hours a week!
Bob Caswell: And how are you good at your job? That's the other thing. We live in America, and if at least in my limited anecdotal experience, if I just put in exactly 40 hours a week, I would underperform. If I had that overhead of every evening covered with soccer practice slash priesthood meeting, I would have to struggle just to keep up with my peers.
Big Families, Middle Children, and Parental Attention
Glenn Ostlund: You know what you're proving right now? That these Mormons who do this get extra blessings and bolster from God!
Brother Jake: Is that what's happening? Or they just—my parents had too many kids, and they just ignored the middle ones. That's really what they did in practical terms. There were eight kids. Kids four through six, it was just like: "Fuck them. They'll be fine. Hopefully they'll turn out." And they did, more or less. The older ones helped with the chores, and they got the brunt of attention at the very beginning before we were swamped by children. And the younger ones—you get a few years at the end to kind of make up for all of it. But the middle ones, it was just like, "You'll always have food and a place to sleep." That was basically all.
Bob Caswell: That's funny, because I kind of identify with that. I come from a family of six kids and I'm number four. I'm smack in the middle. The savings for education kind of were burned through before my time, and then at the very end, it was like, "Oh, but now that we're down to our last one, let's double down and help him out in all these other ways, too." And in the middle is where a couple of us struggled.
Brother Jake: Right. And it's kind of odd, cuz if you asked my siblings, out of the seven of my siblings, probably five of them would immediately say, if they asked who's the favorite son of my mom (who's the surviving parent), five out of seven would say me. Even though I'm the apostate, you know!
Bob Caswell: You're the youngest, right?
Brother Jake: Yeah, I'm the youngest. My parents did the best they could, and having eight kids is crazy. But at the same time, love, time, and attention is a finite resource.
Glenn Ostlund: Time and attention for sure.
Brother Jake: Because there have been numerous studies where face-to-face, in the same room, time spent with a child—that counts. And there are 24 hours in a day. You can love them, but if you're not fucking spending time with them, then shit, I don't know.
Bob Caswell: Theoretically, can you love in a concentrated, better way for 10 minutes versus a shitty 10 minutes where a parent just checks a box?
Brother Jake: Sociological evidence shows it's showing up. Turning the engagement up to 11 doesn't really bump the effect as much. Time is a finite resource, and by extrapolation, attention. At some point, the only way to provide an increase of time and attention to one child is to take it away from another child.
Bob Caswell: What is love if you're not spending time actually engaging? It only matters to you; it doesn't really matter to them. I kind of want to throw my parents a bone a little bit, because there's a story I tell: in high school, I thought I was being super rebellious, and I took off for a weekend with a friend and we drove from Utah to Idaho.
When I came back, my dad was like, "Hey, I didn't see you this morning." I'm like, "Dude, it's been two days! What do you mean this morning?" The fact that I was gone for two nights and my parents didn't notice stuck with me. But being a middle child and having that lack of pamperedness really empowered me with independence and self-sustainability.
Glenn Ostlund: But I hate to tell you, Bob, that story does not throw them a bone! That completely confirms what Jake is saying! How are those not all different flavors of neglect?
Bob Caswell: Well, they didn't do it willfully or maliciously. They just had a lot of kids, not enough money, not enough time. In the end, being a middle child forced me to be more self-sustaining.
Brother Jake: Whereas I'm the youngest, and I have the life skills of a 13-year-old! I haven't paid a bill in five years. I went grocery shopping for the first time in three years two weeks ago. Erica wears the pants, and I like it that way!
Generational Conditioning, Bias, and Raising Kids
Bob Caswell: But couldn't all those spirits from the pre-existence come down just a little bit slower, with a little more love and attention, if we all had four kids instead?
I kind of give my parents a free pass because of this generational gap. But there's residual leftover stuff from how society functioned back then, especially with the church angle, that I can't completely undo. I feel like there's always a little part of me, because of where and when I was raised, that's always going to be a little bit homophobic, sexist, and racist. I fight against it all the time, but it's just not 100% erased.
Brother Jake: Yeah. No, that shit doesn't go away.
Glenn Ostlund: So, Bob, you judge your siblings differently than you judge your parents because of the time in which they were raised?
Bob Caswell: Exactly. It makes me want to multiply and replenish the earth with kids who are raised without that filter perpetuated by the Mormon church! I want to accelerate the next generation not to have to reverse-engineer their personalities like I had to.
Glenn Ostlund: You've got to be careful, Bob, because a couple of your siblings regularly listen.
Bob Caswell: I know, but I've been drinking, so I can blame it on that!
The Atonement as a Cosmic "Reset Button"
Brother Jake: There's this sense within the ex-Mormon community—and really within Mormonism—that the entire atonement is based around the idea that there's some situation where you can hit the reset button and retroactively fix everything that's been wrong with your life. When people leave the church at 30 with two kids, they get a babysitter and go get blackout drunk, but the time to be 19 and drunk is over. There's no atonement catch-all for retroactively applying everything you wish had been different.
Bob Caswell: Is the atonement really a reset button?
Brother Jake: For gay people, or people who grew up in an abusive situation, it's pitched as a reset button: all the suffering, emotional, and psychological trauma of mortality will be undone in the next life, and the paper torn to shreds will be put back together in a perfect state.
Glenn Ostlund: But isn't that like the resurrection, where someone who is blind or has one arm is made whole?
Bob Caswell: Let's bring it back to reality: what about all those men in the church who are perpetually attracted to other women other than their wives? You're told, "Don't feel bad; just keep repenting. In the afterlife, you'll be a god and you'll get more wives anyway, so you'll get to experience all of that later."
Glenn Ostlund: Did you really think that?
Bob Caswell: Indirectly, yes! Any sinful impulse is attributed to the "natural man," and that aspect will be expunged, or fulfilled via polygamy!
Glenn Ostlund: See, I never felt like I had to repent of being attracted to somebody else. If I looked and thought, "Wow, she's really attractive," I didn't feel like that was a sin.
Brother Jake: But as an exalted, celestial being, you wouldn't have any sexual impulse that leads toward something sinful. Whatever aspect of yourself that does that would be gone. In Helaman and Mosiah, it describes people who had a mighty change of heart and had no more disposition to do evil, but to do good continually.
Glenn Ostlund: I always thought the afterlife was so fundamentally different from what we experience now that it's apples to oranges. I wasn't guilt-ridden by being attracted to other women in the ward.
Brother Jake: Someone didn't read enough Boyd K. Packer as an active believer! In Alma 34, it says the same spirit that possesses your body when you leave this life will have power to possess your body in that eternal world. I internalized that every aspect of me not in harmony with the commandments had to be scrubbed out by the atonement like bypass surgery.
Bob Caswell: And did you guys think that when you got married, all of that would just vanish? That's the most naive Mormon mentality ever: "Now that I'm married, I'll never be attracted to another woman." And then you get married and realize, "Wait, that's not true at all!"
Glenn Ostlund: To me, it wasn't carnal. For me, I could be like a sultan who collects hundreds of beautiful, intelligent, fascinating women around me like artwork!
Brother Jake: Some of us just think with our dicks, Glenn! What are you talking about? Debating whether it's worse to want to have sex with all women or collect them as trophies on a platform!
Bob Caswell: Wouldn't it be great to eliminate this stank of religion from sex and just teach the next generation about biology and genuine human connection?
Brother Jake: Sexual monogamy is a practical social trade-off. If you take away the religious guilt, it comes down to: you made a commitment to a person, and being dishonest or hurting them is what's wrong—not that our Father in Heaven will strike you down.
Glenn's Parenting Shift: Ex-Mother-in-Law & The Picture of Jesus
Bob Caswell: Glenn, you had kids as a believer and as a non-believer. Did your faith crisis change how you parented?
Glenn Ostlund: My crisis definitely influenced my parenting. My previous mother-in-law was a very intense, dogmatic person—campaigning for Prop 8, wearing her missionary badge everywhere.
When my oldest daughter, who is 14 now, was about one year old, she learned how to strip off her pajamas and diaper, and would be stark naked in the morning. My ex-wife had a huge issue with it: "This is immoral! Jesus doesn't like naked girls!" She picked her up and held her in front of that ruggedly handsome picture of Jesus in our hallway. I was appalled.
The next morning, we walked in, and she was naked as a jaybird. But before my ex-wife could say a word, my daughter looked up and said: "No, it's okay, Mommy. Jesus says it's okay!" I went, "Yes! Yes!"
Bob Caswell: What about priesthood blessings?
Glenn Ostlund: Priesthood blessings were a huge problem for me early on. I started realizing it was faith healing, a placebo, a relic of magic. The idea that an all-powerful, loving God who knows my child is sick would heal her, but only if I consecrated oil, said the right words in the right order, and held the priesthood—I didn't want my daughters to think they didn't have access to God except through a man. So I made a concerted effort to empower them directly.
Shaye Joins the Podcast
Glenn Ostlund: When she was seven or eight in fourth grade, I even sat down with her and drew anatomical pictures to explain the birds and the bees.
(Noticing his daughter nearby)
Hey, my daughter has been behind me listening the whole time! Shaylee, come over here and sit down for a second. Bob wants to ask you a question.
Bob Caswell: Have you noticed your dad raising you differently from when he was a believing member of the Mormon church to where he is now? Or has he always just been the same person?
Shaye: I feel like he's always been pretty cool. I vaguely remember being in the study downstairs when he drew those pictures in fourth grade and freaking out internally! But I feel like I've always been a lot more open with my dad than with my mom. He became a little more "whatever" after he stopped going to church. I remember when he used to fake being sick so he wouldn't have to go to sacrament meeting!
Bob Caswell: Did you ever hear something weird at church and ask your dad about it?
Shaye: I was never really into the church stuff. I didn't realize sex or drinking was supposedly "bad"—I just knew we didn't do it.
Glenn Ostlund: Do you remember when you were baptized, and they showed that video with the song about the little white dress?
Shaye: Oh, yeah.
Glenn Ostlund: The message that "now you're clean, you're the cleanest person in the room"—it was like nails on a chalkboard to me.
Shaye: The only things I remember were small things, like when I wore skinny jeans for the first time in sixth grade, wore makeup, and asked for a second ear piercing. You and Mom gave me a talk.
Glenn Ostlund: Not because Gordon B. Hinckley told us so, but just because I thought you were too young for it!
Brother Jake: It's midnight where you are, and she's taking her driver's license test tomorrow!
Shaye: It's okay, I'll have coffee in the morning when I wake up.
Brother Jake: That's two sins in the space of eight hours!
Glenn Ostlund: Good night, Shaye. Love you.
Shaye: Good night, guys.
The Latent Ex-Mormon Disposition & The Slippery Slope
Brother Jake: There is a specific disposition in people who leave the church. They started 20 years ago when they were 15 and decided: "Rated-R movies aren't that bad; I'm fucking watching V for Vendetta."
The more I listen to Boyd K. Packer, the more I agree with him from within the context of Mormonism: if you want to stay Mormon, you have to stay 50 miles away from the edge! Because the moment you step over and realize you're not falling, the appeal to authority collapses. Mormonism is a totalitarian religion; it is entirely an appeal to authority.
Bob Caswell: But millions of Mormons watch rated-R movies and stay!
Brother Jake: It's a necessary condition, not a sufficient one. Not everyone who disobeys leaves, but every single person who leaves Mormonism has the disposition to reject authoritarian dictates over their life.
Eventually, you stop holding the church up as the standard against which you measure yourself. You flip the relationship: you become the moral standard, and the church is measured against you. That is the moment the bullet hits.
Full Circle: Escaping External Dogma
Glenn Ostlund: Can we bring this full circle back to ideology?
Brother Jake: That is why I'm so cynical about ideology. I spent so much of my life submitting to an external moral authority that I am fiercely reticent to ever do that again. Whether it's a political party or an institution, if it discourages questioning and demands blind allegiance, I reject it.
Glenn Ostlund: But you're not just sitting on your ass—you're making Brother Jake videos, and we're making Infants on Thrones! It's an intellectual exercise to work through these issues in an honest, open way.
Listener Testimony Outro
(A father prompting his young daughter line-by-line)
Father: Brothers and sisters...
Child: Brothers and sisters...
Father: My name is Ka...
Child: My name is Ka...
Father: From Aurora, Colorado...
Child: From Aurora, Colorado...
Father: And I'd like to bear my testimony...
Child: And I'd like to bear my testimony...
Father: That I know Infants on Thrones is true...
Child: That I know Infants on Thrones is true...
Father: I know this podcast loves me...
Child: I know this podcast loves me...
Father: I know that it teaches the philosophies of men...
Child: I know that it teaches the philosophies of men...
Father: Mingled with humor...
Child: Mingled with humor...
Father: I know you can comment on this episode...
Child: I know you can comment on this episode...
Father: On the website, infantsonthrones.com...
Child: On the website, infantsonthrones.com...
Father: If you really like what you hear...
Child: If you really like what you hear...
Father: You can give the quorum a five-star rating...
Child: You can give the quorum a five-star rating...
Father: If the Holy Ghost prompts you...
Child: If the Holy Ghost prompts you...
Father: You can write a short review on iTunes...
Child: You can write a short review on iTunes...
Father: My dad did...
Child: My dad did...
Father: And I say these things in the name of...
Child: And I say these things in the name of...
Father: Anyone for the closing prayer?
Child: Anyone for the closing prayer?
Father: Amen.
Child: Amen.
Father: Good job!
Post-Episode Announcement
Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund.
And just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.
I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and I'm accepting new clients. So, if you or someone you know is seeking either coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes.
So, thanks again for listening, and now here's your episode.
