Ep 95 – Sacred Experiences

What happens to your sacred experiences once you stop believing in Mormonism? Matt and Kristin share a few of their most sacred experiences and discuss.

Episode 95: Sacred Experiences

Theme Voiceover: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the quorum.
Introduction: Declaration of Atheism

Matt: People of Earth, this is Matt from Infants on Thrones, and I'm here to make an announcement. My name is Matt, and I'm an atheist.

If you're not new to this podcast, then this probably belongs on the front page of a little publication known as Stuff We Already Knew Weekly. And it's true: I haven't been shy about talking about this fact on past episodes. Now, this episode isn't going to be about what an atheist means to me or how I came to hold this view. It might be a good topic for a future episode, but still, I'm here to declare this fact without ambiguity and with clarity. I identify as an atheist, a skeptic, a person who doesn't believe that a god interacts with or influences people, a person that doesn't believe in supernatural events or phenomenon.

And when I disclose this to people, I'm often asked whether or not I've ever had any experiences that make me question my skeptical and atheistic view. This episode answers that question. My wife and I talk about and explore a couple of our sacred experiences, and we discuss how we reconcile them with our current non-believing viewpoint and find out whether or not these sacred experiences are meaningful to us today. This is a topic I wanted to cover for a long time. So, I want to bring my wife on to tell a shared story we have. One of those stories is just too sacred to tell. So, this is my wife, Kristen.
Car Conversation & Background

Kristen: Hi, I'm Kristen. I'm Matt's wife, and Matt rocks.

Matt: As I've been thinking about what experiences have I had in my life that are just too sacred—too sacred to tell, the real special spiritual experiences that are those pearls that just can't be cast before swine of other people. And as I think about it, I have two or three that come to mind. I thought we'd talk about them and see if they really are that spiritual or that sacred. Sound good?

Kristen: Perfect.

Matt: All right. So—

Kristen: Do I have to agree with you?

Matt: About what?

Kristen: I'm just kidding—their sacredness.

Matt: Well, we can decide later. So, we're in the car. That's why you hear some of the noise. So, apologize for the ambient noise, the road noise, and maybe the air conditioning. But figured the way to break up a nice road trip was do a little episode for IoT, chatting together.

Yeah, the first story—I don't know if you know this story, Kristen.

Kristen: Oh, dear.

Matt: But it's the story of how I ultimately decided that we should be married.

Kristen: Well, I should know the story.

Matt: Well, you should know the story, but do you?

Kristen: I think, yeah. I remember sitting—you went to the—you had to go to the temple and think about me, and I was sitting in the visitor center wondering: is he going to come and dump me, or is he going to want to be with me?

Matt: I did go to the temple, so—

Kristen: I went with you, I know!

Matt: Wait, so I remember going to the temple.

Kristen: I wasn't endowed yet, so I had to stay, you know, with the kids in the visitor center.

Matt: Yeah, but this wasn't like a wedding or something. You were just—

Kristen: You just brought me, and you were going into the temple.

Matt: So that was—that's kind of weird. I don't remember doing that. Okay.

Kristen: Went to Subway after, and I'll tell you that exciting trip or Subway experience after.

Matt: Okay, well, all right. We'll get there in a second, but first a little context. Let's talk about where we first met. We met in high school.

Kristen: No, not the pre-existence?

Matt: Did we meet in the pre-existence?

(Song snippet)
"I've seen that smile somewhere before... I've heard your voice..."

Kristen: No, not the pre-existence. High school.

Matt: High school. Eighth grade, probably eighth grade. You were eighth, I was ninth.

Kristen: Yeah, I robbed the cradle! I was in eighth, you were in ninth, and we were in the same ward together.

Matt: Mhm. That's a yes.

Kristen: That's true, yes, that's a yes. Am I on trial, or—?

Matt: We dated for a very brief time when I was a freshman, you were a sophomore.

Kristen: True. But I couldn't date because I was 15, you were 16.

Matt: Yes.

Kristen: Well, we broke up so that you could go date!

Matt: Well, yeah. I wanted to go on a date and told you that I still really liked you, I just wanted to go on a date 'cause I turned 16.

Kristen: I think we call that having your cake and eating it, too. And you dumped me.

Matt: Or we were friends through high school. Never really hooked back up until after my mission. And that mission story is a minisode all in and of itself. We actually already released this story as an episode. If you haven't heard it, you can find it on our website from June 9th, 2014. Go ahead, we'll wait.

Now that you're caught up, we'll continue. But needless to say, when I get off my mission, we didn't date beforehand, but we had known each other for eight years.

Kristen: Yes. But before your mission, you took me out and planted the seed that I should, you know—not wait, but kind of like, "Don't forget me".

Matt: That was a pretty good move.

Kristen: That was a really good move. I didn't forget you, but I was like, "Damn you".

Matt: But you were dating some other dude.

Kristen: Yeah, I was dating.

Matt: But we weren't together.

Kristen: No, didn't even kiss.

Matt: Yeah, you weren't like waiting for me or anything like that on my mission.

Kristen: Nope.

Matt: So, I get back, and very quickly we hook up.

Kristen: Very quickly.

Matt: Like the day or the day after I get back from my mission.

Kristen: Well, you were home probably two or three days, and I called you 'cause I just got home from BYU. I just graduated, came home for the summer.

Matt: All right, so we meet up within a week of me being home.

Kristen: Very brave and called you, and my mom said I was horny because I was calling you. Please edit that, please!

Matt: Oh, that's staying in! Were you horny?

Kristen: Um, no. I didn't even know what horny was back then. I was a perfect Mormon; I just wanted to see you and see if there might be something there.

Matt: Okay, so within a week of me getting home, we start dating.

Kristen: Within one night, we were making out!

Matt: Well, that's true. Well, of course you were horny.

Kristen: Shut up! Just so you all know, that should have been edited out.
Sacred Experience #1: Temple Confirmation & Subway Doubts

Matt: All right, so within a month, though, in true Mormon fashion, there's no way we could just date, right? We can't just figure things out on our own. We've got some decisions to make.

Kristen: Yep, after three weeks.

Matt: We've got to know whether or not we're getting married. So, what does any good Mormon boy returned missionary do in order to find out if he's supposed to get married to this woman?

Kristen: Not follow his heart, but go to the temple.

Matt: That's right—not do pros and cons. Well, I did talk to friends and family.

Kristen: Did they tell you to dump me?

Matt: One person says, "You know, I always think maybe there's something better out there," but he has never been married, so that made me realize maybe not follow his advice. So, I go to the temple, man, because that's the answer to everything. All I need to do is go to the temple, pray about it, and I'll get my answer of whether or not I'm supposed to marry you, whether or not you are my soulmate.

Kristen: Yes.

(Musical Interlude – Tim Minchin / "If I Didn't Have You")
*"If I didn't have you to share my sighs and kiss me and drown me when I cry...
Will I really think that I would have somebody else?
If I didn't have you, someone else would do.
Your love is one in a million, you couldn't buy it at any price.
But of the 9.999 hundred thousand other possible loves,
Statistically, some of them would be equally nice...
Or maybe not as nice, but say smarter than you,
Or dumber, but better at sport or tracing.
I'm just saying I probably..."*

Matt: Well, we didn't think like that back then.

Kristen: It wasn't like if you pass this up, whatever was set up in the eternities is ruined, right?

Matt: Yeah, there's only one person for you, and the Lord will tell you who it is through the Holy Ghost. So I go to the temple, and I sit through the endowment.

Kristen: Did you just groan?

Matt: Well, how can you think when you're doing all these signs and changing your robe 14 times? But anyways, I'm finding that sweet spot of the spirit in the temple.

Kristen: I was waiting for you in the visitor center.

Matt: You came with me in the same car, and you knew why I was going?

Kristen: Yes. Gosh, I don't remember. We were getting serious in three weeks, and you went to the temple to pray and think about our relationship. I was nervous the whole time.

Matt: That's weird. Sorry about that.

Kristen: It's a little douchy: "Listen, baby, of course you want to be with me, but now I've got to go to the temple to see if God wants me to be with you". And there was also a hangup 'cause I did have a missionary! So there was lots of issues.

Matt: And I'm just home off my mission—do I really want to jump into this so quickly? Shouldn't I be dating a whole bunch of girls?

Kristen: Matt was perfect when he got home. He would not break any rules. I wanted you to not be perfect; I tried!

Matt: Okay, stop! So, I go to the temple. I was always taught as a missionary to have a decision made and then ask for confirmation. While I'm sitting in the temple, I say: "I've made the decision, I'm going to marry her. Is this the right thing to do?" And very vividly, what I remember is seeing your face in temple clothes, with the veil up.

Kristen: That is hot! I'm going to barf! You never told me this. How did I look?

Matt: Pretty much how you did in temple clothes. I see you really smiling and happy, from the shoulders up, and I just had this real peace. I was like: that's it, that's my answer. Of course we're supposed to get married.

Kristen: That's adorable. I feel the spirit!

Matt: This is sacred stuff! I remember thinking this is as much an answer to a prayer as I've ever gotten. So I came out, planning on dropping to a knee immediately and saying, "Will you marry me?"

Kristen: That is not what happened! We hugged, you looked unsure, and then you took me to Subway!

Matt: I come out prepared to propose, and immediately when I leave the temple, nothing but doubt enters my mind—like this is not right, this is a horrible idea! The reality of the situation punched me in the face: you've only been dating for three weeks, you barely have been home a month, you're not in school yet, you don't have a job! All the practical things came to mind. So what happens at Subway?

Kristen: You did not look happy. We're sitting eating, and you pretty much tell me, "I can't keep dating just you; I've got to date around". So my thought was: well, then we're going to just be over, because I have a missionary coming home in a month. I knew I wanted to marry you, but if you didn't want to marry me, then I was just going to go back to Utah and get married and teach up there. You broke my heart 'cause I was like, "Oh, I guess now I just have to marry my missionary who I didn't want to marry". So Subway sucked!

Matt: In retrospect, that really sounds like the more responsible choice!

Kristen: Totally. But I was 21, which is old for Mormons not to be married. I was an old maid! If I didn't take you or this missionary coming home, I might not get married.

Matt: So why this became such a spiritual, sacred story that I clung to for years: I'm talking to my dad and telling him about what happened and why we're splitting up. My dad is just not a magical-thinking type guy—total gruff, down-to-earth, no-bullshit kind of guy. And he says: "Well, that's your answer. You were safe in the temple and you got your answer. When you walked out of the temple, you were immediately accosted and bombarded by Satan. All the thoughts you had out of the temple were from Satan".

And I remember thinking, "Oh my gosh, it really is that simple!" And then my dad tells me that months ago, before he even knew Kristen was in the picture, he had a dream that we were getting married!

Kristen: Yeah, you told me that after.

Matt: That was crazy to hear my dad say that. That was my confirmation about the temple, confirmation that God cares about who we marry, and confirmation that if you ask earnestly, you'll get the answer. Within a couple days of talking to my dad, I got a ring and we were engaged.

Spoiler alert: we got married, and we're pretty damn happy.

Kristen: I'm pretty damn happy! But the whole time while you were going through all of this spiritual trauma, I was like: I came home, saw you, and I want to marry Matt.
Sacred Experience #2: Adopting Tori in the Marshall Islands

Matt: That was the most sacred spiritual experience, until two years later. This one is something we both experienced related to Tori.

Kristen: This would be my very first spiritual experience—the only time I can say that I've gotten an answer to a prayer.

Matt: We'd been married about a year and a half, two years. I had the chance to work for an adoption agency facilitating adoptions out of the Marshall Islands. My partner and I were going to help about 10 families adopt. It was summer, Kristen wasn't teaching, so she decided to go with us.

Kristen: And we had just stopped using birth control and decided let's try to have a baby. One of the first places we go on the island is to a family Matt was very close with on his mission, and there was a 10-year-old girl they wanted to place with a family. I had this overwhelming feeling: maybe we're supposed to take this girl home and adopt her? I kept thinking, "This is crazy—I'm 23, she's 10, and I teach fourth grade". We get in the car and I tell Matt, and Matt had the exact same feeling!

Over the next eight days, we're talking and praying about it. It just didn't feel quite right. On the eighth night, we're on our knees praying: "Heavenly Father, we've made the decision to adopt this 10-year-old girl. Please confirm if this is the right decision, and if not, let us know".

As soon as we say amen, Paul—our best friend and Matt's adoption partner—walks into the hotel room and says: "Sylvia wants you to take Tori (Torika) home". Tori was Sylvia's 18-month-old little girl who had been sick since birth with pneumonia, bronchitis, and a heart murmur. Both Matt and I felt this overwhelming answer: that's who we're supposed to take home! We just said amen, and Heavenly Father opened the doors.

Matt: Never in my life has anything been more clearly correct.

Kristen: We got guardianship and adopted her. When we got home, we took her to the doctor within a week. We learned she had a hole in her heart, an enlarged heart, and a patent ductus arteriosus—a connection between the aorta and pulmonary artery forcing blood where it shouldn't go, causing her heart and lungs to become enlarged and muscularized. That was the cause of all her respiratory hospitalizations. At 18 months, she weighed only 17 pounds.

Matt: The surgeon told us: "How did you know to get her now? This is one of the easiest things to fix, but also one of the most deadly. If you don't fix it within a specific window—between age one and three—the heart becomes so muscularized that you get perpetual pulmonary hypertension and the heart gives out. She would not have made it another year and a half; she would have died." And we said, "We didn't know—it was a miracle".

Kristen: And by the time she had surgery, I was six months pregnant! Had we known I was pregnant out in the Marshall Islands, there's no way we would have adopted her. So to us, that was confirmation bias that God was controlling this.

Matt: She went through open-heart surgery. At 2:00 in the morning, the surgeon wakes me up, completely excited: "Come here, you've got to see this!" He puts up her pre-op X-ray and her post-op X-ray from just minutes before. He says: "In 20 years as a surgeon, I have never seen a reaction to surgery this quick. Within six hours, her heart is basically normal size".

Kristen: And the hole closed on its own, which the doctor said rarely happens at that age! Tori is 17 now and everything has been fine. That was our sacred miracle.
Reconciling Sacred Experiences as Atheists

Matt: So how do we reconcile our belief now? What is your take on that?

Kristen: Tori is our little miracle. I grew up a good little Mormon girl praying for a burning in the bosom and never got one. This was my first and only experience where I thought: God is real, there are miracles. When we were leaving the church, this was the one thing that kept me thinking maybe there's something. It had nothing to do with Mormonism, just: does God exist and answer prayers?

It's taken me years to realize—using Matt's term—that she is a happy coincidence. We're lucky we were there at the right time, and lucky Matt had a great relationship with Sylvia. I don't know if I believe anymore that it was from God, but it is still my one hangup where I feel lucky to be her mom.

Matt: As an atheist, what I've come to think about is: good things do happen, just like bad things happen. Sometimes bad things conspire to create tragedies where one small change results in chaos and pain, and nobody calls that a miracle. Sometimes shit just happens. Similarly, when good things happen, it's not supernatural—it is a happy coincidence. The fact that it resulted in this beautiful relationship with our daughter is something to be celebrated, but it's not magic.
Tim Minchin & Ann Druyan: Finding Meaning in the Cosmos

(Beat Poem Excerpt – Tim Minchin / "Storm")
Tim Minchin: *"Isn't this enough? Just this world? Just this beautiful, complex, wonderfully unfathomable natural world? How does it so fail to hold our attention that we have to diminish it with the invention of cheap man-made myths and monsters? If you're so into your Shakespeare, lend me your ear: 'To gild refined gold, to paint the lily, to throw perfume on the violet... is just fucking silly.'
I am a tiny, tiny, insignificant, ignorant bit of carbon. I have one life, and it is short and unimportant. But thanks to recent scientific advances, I get to live twice as long as my great-great-great-uncles, and twice as long to live this life of mine—twice as long to love this wife of mine."*

Matt: We've lost people in our lives this past year, and the quote we keep coming back to is from Ann Druyan, Carl Sagan's wife, after Carl died.

Kristen: Sorry, I'm crying. Not because of the spirit, but because I just lost my mom, and I love what you're going to say.

Matt (Reading Ann Druyan):
*"When my husband died, because he was so famous and known for not being a believer, many people would come up to me—it still sometimes happens—and ask me if Carl changed at the end and converted to a belief in an afterlife. They also frequently ask me if I think I will see him again.
Carl faced his death with unflagging courage and never sought refuge in illusions. The tragedy was that we knew we would never see each other again. I don't ever expect to be reunited with Carl, but the great thing is that when we were together for nearly 20 years, we lived with a vivid appreciation of how brief and precious life is. We never trivialized the meaning of death by pretending it was anything other than a final parting.
Every single moment that we were alive and we were together was miraculous—not miraculous in the sense of inexplicable or supernatural. We knew we were beneficiaries of chance, that pure chance could be so generous and so kind. That we could find each other, as Carl wrote so beautifully in Cosmos, in the vastness of space and the immensity of time. That we could be together for 20 years—that is something which sustains me, and it's much more meaningful.
The way he treated me and the way I treated him, the way we took care of each other and our family while he lived, that is so much more important than the idea that I will see him someday. I don't think I'll ever see Carl again, but I saw him. We saw each other. We found each other in the cosmos. And that was wonderful."*

Kristen: When my mom was passing away, Matt read this quote to me on the way up to say goodbye. My siblings are all very active in the church, and at her bedside, they kept talking about the veil opening and how we're going to see her again. It drove me crazy because it felt like they were just going through the motions: "Death is fine, we'll see her again". But in those final minutes, I didn't believe that anymore. This was it—I was saying goodbye to my mom forever, and I felt so lucky that I got to know her and that she was mine.

Matt: When we talk about sacred or spiritual experiences, they aren't supernatural miracles. They are chance being kind. In a universe where chance can often be cruel and destroy, it is good to recognize when chance is generous. Connecting with another person in the vastness of space and the immensity of time is special and should be celebrated from the rooftops, but it is not supernatural. Those are our sacred experiences: happy coincidences.

Kristen: I wanted to say that I'm lucky I found you in the cosmos.

Matt: We're having fun on this little ride on the pale blue dot. I love you.

Kristen: I love you. Anyone for the closing prayer?
Carl Sagan: "Pale Blue Dot" Reading

(Carl Sagan reading)
Carl Sagan: "From this distant vantage point, the Earth might not seem of any particular interest. But for us, it's different. Consider again that dot. That's here. That's home. That's us. On it everyone you love, everyone you know, everyone you ever heard of, every human being who ever was, lived out their lives. The aggregate of our joy and suffering, thousands of confident religions, ideologies, and economic doctrines, every hunter and forager, every hero and coward, every creator and destroyer of civilization, every king and peasant, every young couple in love, every mother and father, hopeful child, inventor and explorer, every teacher of morals, every corrupt politician, every 'superstar,' every 'supreme leader,' every saint and sinner in the history of our species lived there—on a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam.

The Earth is a very small stage in a vast cosmic arena. Think of the rivers of blood spilled by all those generals and emperors so that, in glory and triumph, they could become the momentary masters of a fraction of a dot. Think of the endless cruelties visited by the inhabitants of one corner of this pixel on the scarcely distinguishable inhabitants of some other corner, how frequent their misunderstandings, how eager they are to kill one another, how fervent their hatreds.

Our posturings, our imagined self-importance, the delusion that we have some privileged position in the Universe, are challenged by this point of pale light. Our planet is a lonely speck in the great enveloping cosmic dark. In our obscurity, in all this vastness, there is no hint that help will come from elsewhere to save us from ourselves.

There is perhaps no better demonstration of the folly of human conceits than this distant image of our tiny world. To me, it underscores our responsibility to deal more kindly with one another, and to preserve and cherish the pale blue dot, the only home we've ever known."

Matt: Thank you for listening to Infants on Thrones.
Post-Episode Announcement

Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund.

And just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.

I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and I'm accepting new clients. So, if you or someone you know is seeking either coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes.

So, thanks again for listening, and now here's your episode.

Ep 95 – Sacred Experiences
Broadcast by