Ep 58 – Dazed and Confirmed

If you have ever felt a little weighed down by the legacy of your Mormon ancestors — and if you have ever turned to alternative methods of self-medication — then this may be the episode for you. Tom, Randy, Jake and Glenn are joined by listener Brad to discuss his far out essay “Dazed and Confirmed.”

Episode 58: Dazed and Confirmed

(Background banter from mission audio cassette)
Elder: "Dumb."
Companion: "It's not dumb. Anyway..."
Elder: "Hello. This is infant Glenn Ostlund. For the sake of this battery, if you run out, I will give you the talk of the century."

Glenn Ostlund: In the fall of 1992, I was a missionary living in Matsue, Japan with the two elders you're hearing in the background.

(Background audio continues)
Companion: "The missionary work is not progressing in this ward because of you!"
Glenn Ostlund: They were crazy. I was not.
Companion: "The missionaries bust their butts day in and day out, P-days included, to do what they can, and you—"
Glenn Ostlund: They were irreverent and obnoxious. I was not.
Companion: "You sit back on me when we..."
Glenn Ostlund: President Utagawa, if you are listening to this now, I swear it was them all along, not me.
Companion: "Show off your double chin, show off your double chin! That's for nachos, your stupid nachos!"

Glenn Ostlund: Today I have one of those elders here to admit it all right in front of everyone: Elder Brad Phillips. Oh, how far you sunk, and then rose, and then sunk all over again.

(Background audio snippet)
Brad Phillips: "And for those of you that want to hear my Scotty imitation, wait for the skin."
Glenn Ostlund: Oh, Phil, you kill me. But he does do a pretty mean Darth Vader.
Companion: "Do your Japanese Darth Vader!"
Companion: "Japanese Darth Vader, ladies and gentlemen!"
Companion: "He's going to say, Ohayō, Stormtrooper!"
Glenn Ostlund: For those of you out there, that is "Good morning, Stormtrooper". Yeah, those guys were just wrong. But not me. I should have been AP.

Theme / Intro: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor with you. We are the quorum.
Introduction

Glenn Ostlund: So yeah, this is kind of a treat for me. Today I'm joined by Tom—

Tom Perry: One of my ancestors is Joseph Allen Stout, who was brother of Hosea Stout, who is the Nauvoo Chief of Police.

Glenn Ostlund: —Randy—

Randy Snyder: My great-grandpa, Frank Snyder, was a hobo.

Glenn Ostlund: —and Jake—

Brother Jake: My great-great-great-great-grandfather was Jesse N. Smith, who was the first cousin of Joseph Smith. And so there was that big thing kind of hanging over my head.

Glenn Ostlund: —to discuss another listener-submitted essay, and this time the listener is a guy I lived with for a couple of months on my mission. A great guy, a hilarious guy, and today he has an essay for us which I titled for him on his behalf. You may eventually understand why. So take it away, Brad, with your essay: Dazed and Confirmed.
Essay: Dazed and Confirmed by Brad Phillips

Brad Phillips: I don't think there was ever a time that I didn't really think of myself as LDS. Growing up, I remember sitting during family home evenings and listening to my father—and my mother, for that matter—talk about our ancestors four or five generations back that had been righteous enough to listen to the missionaries, to be baptized, and to come to the States. They were the early settlers of Nauvoo. They crossed the plains and settled in Utah. And we were told from the time that we were kids, all of us, that we came from pioneer stock.

We came from good, righteous people, and the name that we bore and the heritage that we had was something to be proud of. In fact, whenever you'd be leaving the house, it was: "Remember who you are and the name that you bear, and bear it well," to remind us to do what we should.

The interesting thing is, as I got into high school, I didn't make the best choices. I was really kind of a partier. I liked to get out, and we got into a crowd where we would drink during high school lunch break. We'd go have a couple of beers and come back to school, and really didn't care much about school. But that was always in the back of my mind: "Boy, I'm letting somebody down somewhere". Largely, it pushed me into a double life where on Sunday I was the Mormon youth that my parents always were proud about. During the week, I would go do my own thing, run with my friends, make whatever choices. And that was okay. It was always in the back of my head that I was going to serve a mission at 19, and after that, go to some church school, and life would be easy in concept.

So I went on a wrestling scholarship to a nearby college. I fell in with a really rough crowd there. In fact, I was living in a house where I was the only non-convicted felon. At once upon a time, there were six of us: five felons and me. And you know, we had a great time. I think of the blinders falling off of my eyes as I'm seeing people doing different illicit drugs, booze was everywhere, and we had a great time.

I got into a little bit of the psychedelic scene. I haven't thought about it in a lot of years, but funny stories about seeing different things under the influence. I remember standing next to a mirror trying to remember what side of the mirror I was on, or chit-chatting with John Lennon. Funny things happened.

So I really came from a bad place, but that whole time growing up, that thought that I would serve a mission, that thought that I had ancestors, that family pressure to do the right thing, ultimately put me in a place where after that freshman year, I decided I would go on a mission. And largely, that's where life started stacking up. It took me a little bit of extra time to really get right with the church and all of that. A year later, I did receive a mission call to serve in Japan, and that's where I met Glenn.

Actually, Glenn was in my first apartment. And that was an interesting time, being with some missionaries that had been out for a while, with me being kind of new. It was kind of an easy way to slide into the mission life, I guess. But one of the big things to remember was that there were some jaded missionaries there that really were kind of negative on the politics of everything, and I got a little bit jaded, too, I guess. But after that, I kind of settled in, had a good mission, and did all the right things on paper. My dad received all the district leader, zone leader, and trainer notification letters, and he was very proud of his son.

When I came back, I was really ready to be that Mormon elder that is in the script. I went to Ricks College and had a great time. Being a returned missionary at Ricks College when it was a two-year school, you really were a man among boys. You could date whoever you wanted; you were validated. You were a made man in that area.

I served an internship, went to BYU Hawaii where I met my wife, graduated, and took a job. It was kind of interesting that at that time, trying to do all that the church taught, I was married in the temple, my wife and I were both faithful Saints, starting to have kids, but there wasn't contentment. Deep down, I would see things that would just bother me a little bit, and I couldn't put my finger on it.

They would be things like talking about people that weren't LDS. It bothered me that we used the LDS church to validate someone. They could be really good people, but if they weren't Mormon, they're not quite good enough to date or to be with. They could be a sleazeball, but if they're LDS, that was better than a very good non-LDS. That double culture, that double standard bothered me.

Then you'd be in there talking about movies that you saw. If it was a rated-R movie, you would get called out as, "Boy, you're living on the edge". And then they're telling you about some PG-13 movie that was equally crappy, if not a little bit worse. I started really feeling like the LDS church in a lot of ways was like the old Jewish religion that would count how many steps you took on Sunday to determine whether you kept the Sabbath or not. It was more about the cultural principles than it really was the saving principles that seemed to start to matter. And that started me really thinking: how true can the church really be if we put so much pressure on things that really are neither here nor there in the big scheme of things, even the Word of Wisdom?

That was something early on I'd kind of battled, and for a lot of years had put it off and battled—I say "enjoyed" is really what I mean. But I'm thinking: before Joseph Smith, there were millions of people that lived, millions of prophets that were righteous and did all those things. They're all in heaven, and I guarantee you they had wine. So where along the way in the last 150 years did things change where a glass of wine will keep you out of heaven?

So I'm starting to stack these things together, and things don't add up. You hear God's eternal and things don't change. Well, the Word of Wisdom is kind of a new thing. Polygamy kind of came and went. Blacks didn't have the priesthood; now they do. And you start saying: well, is it truly from God, or is it not?

Finally, I just really couldn't do it anymore. For me, it's a new decision. My wife and I, in the last couple of months, have formally decided that we are done. We were less active for at least the last couple of years, but we are done. I've told a couple of my siblings that, "Hey, it's not for me". And it's kind of funny—it's been a freeing conversation to say, "Look, I'm done with this".

Last thing: I would think that my ancestors are proud of the decision I've made to do things for me, not to do things for anybody else. And I couldn't be more happy.
The Panel Discussion: Living with Felons & Ancestry Pressure

Glenn Ostlund: All right, well, let's get going then. I listened to your essay with my wife the other day, and she was just cracking up, Brad.

Brad Phillips: What part was so funny?

Glenn Ostlund: I think the first time she laughed really hard was when you mentioned that you were the only non-convicted felon in your apartment. And then pretty quickly after that when you said, "We had so much fun," she was cracking up.

Brad Phillips: In that house or duplex apartment, we had pictures on the wall that were Hustler centerfolds. Not like the tasteful Playboy centerfolds, but the Hustler ones—

Glenn Ostlund: Where they've got their hands spread.

Brad Phillips: Yeah. My dad came to visit me once—beer cans everywhere. It was brutal. He's just looking, and he was disappointed, maybe is the right word.

Glenn Ostlund: Disappointed? I'm surprised he didn't have a heart attack!

Brad Phillips: Well, see, the other part of it was I moved midway through the year because my parents were pestering me, since I was only a half-hour away. Didn't tell them. This was pre-cell phone, pre-whatever, so they didn't know where I was at. I was off the grid. So when they finally found me, it was just like, "Hey, we've got to pull the prodigal son in". So anything I did was, "That's okay, Brad". It was awesome.

Glenn Ostlund: Are you wanting to use your last name, or are you wanting to not, because it's still the last name of your ancestors and we don't want to sully their last name?

Brad Phillips: It would kind of cheapen it if I said Jacob or Brad Dough.

Glenn Ostlund: So how are you thinking about using it?

Brad Phillips: By saying Phillips.

Glenn Ostlund: Oh, phonetically!

Brad Phillips: Yeah, actually pronouncing it.

Glenn Ostlund: Well, I'm just curious, because I wanted to ask each one of the guys here if you had the same kind of experience that Brad described about having to live up to your ancestors. Because the five of us sitting here, our ancestors could have been fighting over the same wife or sharing them. Did you guys have ancestors going back to Kirtland and Nauvoo?

Brother Jake: Yeah. In my case, my great-great-great-great-grandfather was Jesse N. Smith, who was the first cousin of Joseph Smith. That was a big thing hanging over my head. It really helped break that illusion, though, when I found out that there was just a long, long chain and history of sexual abuse in my family. So that helped crush that mentality of living up to the perfect family name.

Glenn Ostlund: What about you, Tom?

Tom Perry: One of my ancestors is Joseph Allen Stout, who was brother of Hosea Stout, who is the Nauvoo Chief of Police. I've got Joseph Allen's journal that my dad passed along to me. He actually talks about having his own doubts from time to time: "Am I doing the right thing? Is this all worth it?" And then the next morning he's like, "So I started praying and reading my scriptures". It was like a daily shelf thing that he kept throwing on there.

Glenn Ostlund: And what's the timeframe? Nauvoo—is this pre-martyrdom?

Tom Perry: Pre-Mountain Meadows; we're talking Nauvoo, man.

Glenn Ostlund: Randy, did you have anything to add to the whole ancestry thing?

Randy Snyder: On my dad's side, my ancestry isn't proud. My great-grandpa, Frank Snyder, was a hobo.

Glenn Ostlund: Was he a Mormon hobo?

Randy Snyder: No, he came from somewhere back east, rode the rails, and at age 36 jumped off the rails in Salt Lake City, found my great-grandmother who was age 14, and impregnated her. Then he had a few more kids, was a total alcoholic, ended up on Skid Row in Ogden, and died in a pauper's grave. So our genealogy stops with my great-grandpa Frank down that line because nobody knew where he was from.

Tom Perry: I still can't believe that he was an actual hobo that rode the rail lines! That's the perfect stereotype.

Brad Phillips: Hey, those guys still exist. I work in logistics, and a lot of stuff we bring in by rail. We've had incidents where hobos will break open the seals to these tanker cars that bring in bulk sugar, and they will sleep on top of it. We've had to reject rail cars because you've got hobos making a nest in ingredients for Cocoa Puffs.

Randy Snyder: That's my heritage! On my mom's side, they converted in Denmark and immigrated to Salt Lake in the 1850s. On my wife's side, one of her ancestors was John Solomon Fulmer. The night before Joseph Smith was killed in Carthage, he had about 14 of his closest followers, and they drank wine and sang hymns and read from the Book of Mormon. Joseph had wine smuggled in. My wife's dad tells that story with pride.

Glenn Ostlund: On my mom's side, Philemon C. Merrill was a bodyguard of Joseph Smith and in the Mormon Battalion. And Artemus Millet, who helped build the Kirtland Temple, was on my grandfather's side.

Brad Phillips: We go back to Vincent Knight in Kirtland, who helped buy the land.

Glenn Ostlund: Did you guys get the same pressure that Brad did about living up to your ancestors?

Brad Phillips: My parents had this belief that when we die and go to the other side, our ancestors will ask us if we bore that name honorably, or if we did anything to soil or stain the name. It was viewed as this relic from the past that we pass on, and if you did anything to destroy the name, you would have to answer for it. We heard stories of early conversions, miracles, and sacrifices. My great-grandfather remembered meeting Porter Rockwell as a young boy. I have a cousin who named his son Porter because of that tie.
The Allure of Rebellion & Compartmentalization

Brother Jake: One thing I noticed in the essay, Brad, is every time you described a lifestyle that wasn't Mormonism, you'd start out saying, "Yeah, I made some bad choices or fell in with a rough crowd," but then you'd immediately follow it up with, "and we had a great time! It was fantastic!" Do you still feel ambivalence about those choices?

Brad Phillips: I grew up with this very traditional upbringing where you're going to serve a mission, and you didn't make plans beyond age 19. But on the flip side, I was very curious. The first beer I ever had, I was 14 or 14 and a half. It was a Coors Light—the most horrible first beer ever, frothy and warm, but it was fun to be part of that. I'm a natural extrovert, so it wasn't the beer; it was being able to connect, laugh, and joke. There was guilt—thinking great-grandpa is looking at me and I'm letting him down—but the moment was such a great time. So I ended up compartmentalizing: I've got two selves—the one that does this, and the one that goes to church.

Randy Snyder: I was the exact same way. I was straight-laced until my sophomore year of high school. Then the curiosity hit because they make it such a forbidden fruit. We finally went to a friend's house where the parents weren't around, they gave me a beer, and I mixed it with a can of Kern's nectar fruit juice just to choke it down. It was a thrill to do what we weren't supposed to do. Eventually we got into smoking pot. Then I'd go bless or pass the sacrament on Sunday and totally compartmentalize.

Brad Phillips: In PPI interviews with the bishop every six months, it was a conscious decision: I'm going to stare that guy right in the eye, I'm not going to blink, and I'm not going to show a sign of weakness while I was lying.

Tom Perry: Is anybody else feeling uncomfortable? Judas Priest, I'm feeling terribly uncomfortable right now! The thought of consuming alcohol or marijuana was so far outside of what I'd be comfortable doing. And you walk up to your bishop full of demons, staring him down without a shred of conscience! I would walk in there thinking the bishop had the spirit of discernment and could see right through me! I'd be like, "Uh, I touched myself, but nothing happened! It won't happen again, I swear!"

Brother Jake: I'm feeling terrible right now because I was in there for weeks crushed under the burden of touching a boob, and you guys were out there smoking weed without flinching!

Glenn Ostlund: What you guys are hearing right now, I heard from Brad when he was a green bean missionary in Japan. He and this elder, Berbert, were talking about dropping acid and laughing. I was sitting there thinking, "That sounds so cool, but I'm so glad I'm the righteous one in this apartment". But getting to know Brad and Berbert was a turning point on my mission where I became less judgmental. I realized that for them, the mission was like boot camp to get their lives back on track.

Brad Phillips: That was true. I was the only non-convicted felon in my apartment in college. Did I have a testimony that the church was true? I don't know that I did. But I had a testimony that the life path I was on was wrong. And if what you're doing is wrong, the opposite feels like church.
Missionary Shenanigans in Japan

Glenn Ostlund: There was a time on my mission where the measure of success was becoming AP. I made senior companion in four months and district leader in a year. But then I saw the political BS and guys who were ambitious, and I realized I didn't want to be that guy. When I transferred into Brad's apartment, it was a demotion for me, and I was jaded.

Brad Phillips: The apartment had evolved past politics. You guys were willing to listen to music. In the beginning, it was tough because I didn't have the ear for Japanese. I'd look up half of one word and half of another in the dictionary and couldn't find it, and I'd fall asleep in discussions. But in the evenings, Glenn was a practical joker. We would call different zone leaders.

Glenn Ostlund: There was this one zone leader who had aspirations for AP written all over him. We convinced Brad to call him up, pretend he was an anonymous elder in his zone, and confess that he was having problems with wet dreams! And we recorded the whole thing and laughed!

Glenn Ostlund: What about the time you and Berbert went to go see Basic Instinct?

Tom Perry: Dude, that really happened?

Brad Phillips: We didn't know it was that graphic! The mission president eventually found out and asked me, "Did you go see a movie?" I said, "Yes." He asked what kind of movie it was. I said, "It was a Michael Douglas movie". And being Japanese, he had no context and just said, "Okay"!

Glenn Ostlund: And when the sister missionaries were transferring, you and Berbert went into their apartment and had a sword fight with your light sabers in their bathroom!

Brad Phillips: Crossing streams!

Brad Phillips: And then I had that companion, Yoji Hasegawa. He showed up with a bad back, slept in my futon, rode my bike, and made me run next to him! He was built like a sumo wrestler and didn't give a crap. He'd take off riding my bike, saying his back hurt, and I was jogging next to him thinking, "What an asshole!"
Turning Straight-Laced and the Slow Disaffection

Glenn Ostlund: But at what point did you start praying on your own and really believing?

Brad Phillips: Right after you transferred out, the mission president told me: "Elder Phillips, if you're not here to be a missionary, we can send you home now, or you can shape up". I got transferred to Yamaguchi with a straight-laced companion. I had my two turtles with me, and I thought, "I've come too far to go home now". I started getting up at 4:45 every morning, showered, put on my suit and tie, did scripture study, and was as straight-laced as could be. I built a testimony, got made senior companion, zone leader, and trainer. When I got to Ricks College, my cousins laughed at me because I was so Peter Priesthood.

Randy Snyder: It sounds like the wheels came off the bus for you not because of doctrine initially, but because the social culture chipped away at you.

Brad Phillips: That was a big piece. At Ricks and BYU Hawaii, I got in trouble for hair being too long or having a goatee. But once I got married and had kids, I noticed that people who believed the doctrine were often less Christlike. They looked down on non-Mormons, and excused awful behavior in Mormons just because they checked the LDS box. That double standard eroded my confidence.

Then the first doctrinal piece hit: the Pearl of Great Price. Finding out that the papyrus Joseph Smith translated wasn't written by Abraham, but was a common funerary text from the Book of the Dead. And then people shifted the narrative to say, "Well, maybe it was just a catalyst that inspired him". We were moving the goalposts around new facts. Once that unraveled, everything else fell apart.
Hallucinogens, Authenticity, and Dropping the Facade

Brother Jake: Having experienced the wilder side before your mission and then going back to Mormonism, how do you view those experiences now?

Brad Phillips: I never had an open dialogue with my parents. I was the only one of five boys who didn't get his Eagle Scout. There was so much pressure to be this cookie-cutter youth that I couldn't reach out for help when I was struggling. Living that double life gives you empathy for people who have to compartmentalize, like closeted gay people. Ever since I came out and said, "I'm done," my relationships have been so much better because there are no secrets.

Glenn Ostlund: Tell the John Lennon mop story!

Brad Phillips: My freshman year of college, we were tinkering with LSD and listening to the Beatles. There was an upside-down mop head in the corner, and my roommate put circular John Lennon sunglasses on it. In my altered state, my mind filled in the details and it looked like John Lennon. People walked up and asked, "Who are you talking to?" I said, "John Lennon!" They looked at the mop with sunglasses, and I sat there having a full conversation with him for 20 or 30 minutes!

Glenn Ostlund: And the story in the pickup truck!

Brad Phillips: We were in a little Nissan pickup, three of us, tripping on acid. I was sitting by the door and felt so isolated. We stopped at a rest stop, and I said, "I have to sit in the middle". So we switch, and two minutes later the guy on the passenger side taps my shoulder and says, "Man, you were right! This sucks being over here!" So I had to put my arms around both of them and say, "We're all together, guys"!
Closing

Glenn Ostlund: Brad, your wife was the one who suggested you write this essay. Did she say that we all sound like Utah Mormons?

Brad Phillips: She did! She listened to three episodes and said, "Do they know they all sound like Utah Mormons?" You have that general authority cadence and pronunciation.

Tom Perry: Well, Brad's wife, you are awesome!

Glenn Ostlund: Thank you for listening to another episode of Infants on Thrones. Check out our website at infantsonthrones.com for our new survey. And thank you for the iTunes reviews—once we hit 100 ratings, we're throwing a pizza party!

Anyone for the closing prayer?

(Outro music & audio clip)
Retroactive Announcement

Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund. And just real quick, I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.

I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and I'm accepting new clients. So, if you or someone you know is seeking either coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes. So, thanks again for listening, and now here's your episode.

Ep 58 – Dazed and Confirmed
Broadcast by