Ep 51 – The Summons: Tom Phillips vs. Thomas S. Monson – Part 3
Episode 51: The Summons: Tom Phillips vs Thomas S. Monson (Part 3)
Intro: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor with you. We are the quorum.
Glenn Ostlund: Okay, if you're listening to this, I assume that you've listened to Part 1 and Part 2. So, let's skip all the intro mumbo jumbo and just pick up where we left off. This is Matt wrapping things up with Tom Phillips, and then we're going to have some panel discussion that fills out most of Part 3. So, here you go.
Matt Long: I can only speak for me. My understanding of what's going on has really increased from talking to you and listening to you weigh in on this. I really appreciate it. Makes a lot more sense to me.
Scott: Yeah, absolutely. Thank you, Tom. We really appreciate it.
Tom Phillips: Well, thank you for the opportunity. As I said at the beginning, I was obviously a little bit worried about saying too much because I don't want to divulge things that would be prejudicial either to myself and my own case, or to Mr. Monson's case for that matter. But again, I've just tried to be as open as I can about it.
Scott: What I find so interesting is to clarify the misunderstandings and the misperceptions about the procedures and how this goes on. So, to the extent that it educates other people, I think you're on good footing. If your legal team thinks differently, certainly let us know.
Tom Phillips: Oh, I just said that at the beginning. I was just a bit worried. Obviously, you maybe say things that later on you regret, but I'm not aware at this point that I've said anything that I can't be requoted on, but who knows when you'll hear it again.
I mean, it was more a question of being misunderstood, and I think you guys have been extremely good at making sure you've elicited from me any misunderstanding that there is. So, I think you've given me the opportunity to clarify that. And this is a much better way than me looking at the thousands and thousands of posts that are going around with all sorts of pontification on armchair amateur lawyers giving their merits or otherwise of the case, and I can't be going around answering all those questions. So, I appreciate you guys giving me this opportunity to clarify.
Matt Long: You know, our intent, I think, was to try to be a little more critical than maybe we've come off here. And I'm sure we're going to get hit on that. But from my perspective, it was difficult to be really critical because you clarified things when a question was posed to you. So, I think some of the things we thought, "Oh, well, we should challenge him on this or that," it became moot after hearing your explanation. That's my perspective anyway. I don't know what the guys think.
Scott: Yeah. No, I think that's fair to say. In terms of the end result, I think it's still a little bit early to say exactly how this is going to shake out. It just seems like there are ways that it could, unfortunately, fizzle out that we may not be able to contemplate right now. But I think that after talking with you, it certainly sounds much more like a sure thing, or it sounds much more confident than it's perceived as being online. So I think in that respect, this is very useful.
Tom Phillips: I think also in this regard, what has disappointed me is the immediate response from the church with their PR department. They've immediately dismissed this as just a nothing, trivial—President Monson will not attend, there are no charges, and they've not addressed one allegation, but they've just thrown it out there. And that is typical, and again that is misinformation, that is lying. That could be added to the offense by their PR department if Mr. Monson has allowed this to be done. I mean, I've actually got evidence of instructions sent out by his PR department which, if I wanted to, I could take action against that.
Matt Long: Can I ask you, if the Crown Prosecution was to make the decision to kill it, is there a review process or an appeal that could be done of their review and their decision?
Tom Phillips: Yes. If they were to dismiss this, this goes to the Attorney General and the Prime Minister as far as I'm concerned.
Matt Long: And so that is procedurally what you have available if they dismiss it—then to have the Attorney General review it?
Tom Phillips: Well, let's say it's not so much an appeal. First of all, for them to dismiss it, they have to pass the two tests I've told you about.
First of all, is it in the public benefit? I don't see how it can fail that. This is a widespread fraud. If it was isolated to one person, really the public aren't interested in that. But you bring in the British taxpayer, this is in the public benefit. So, there's no way they can fail it for that reason.
The only reason they can fail it is they say this hasn't got a chance in court. Now, let me just tell you about what's happened recently in the courts in England. Recently, some renowned celebrities have been brought before the courts on charges of sexually harassing people 40 or 50 years ago.
Scott: Yeah. This was the BBC presenter, right?
Tom Phillips: Well, yeah. One of them's actually in prison right now, but recently at least two of them, actors from I think Coronation Street, have been acquitted of the charges. Now, the Crown Prosecution Service brought those to court.
Now, what I'm saying in this submission, I have far more evidence. And please, I'm actually not saying whether those people were guilty or not of their offense. If they were not guilty, then I'm really pleased they were acquitted. If they were guilty and got off, I really feel for their victims whose voice in court was dismissed for whatever reason.
But I am not relying on: how do you remember something happened when you had a car journey with this man 40 or 50 years ago? You trial lawyers will know how you can put doubts in people's minds. No, I'm presenting documentary evidence and testimony from Professor X who's an Egyptologist, Professor Y who is a biologist—whatever you want, I will have in those disciplines in court testifying that these statements are false. It's not a question of, "Well, I think 40 or 50 years ago he may have touched me inappropriately or not".
So my contention, the reason I'm going into this and saying, right, if the CPS are willing to take cases like that, they haven't got a chance of dismissing this on inadequate evidence—not one chance. As I say, the only thing they can do here is political. And as far as I'm concerned, if they do that, I'm sitting in the Prime Minister's office to understand why politics is entering into a criminal fraud case with a corporation. It's not a church; it's a corporation.
I mean, if I were a sensible person, what I would have done back in those days was not breathe a word to anyone and continued in what they wanted me to do, whether they wanted me to be a mission president or a member of the First Quorum of the Seventy or whatever, and just kept my mouth shut and been like the good boy, and then at some appropriate time blurted it all out. That would be sensible.
I'm not sensible like that. I can't live the lie, for a start, and play the game. It would be too painful. I wouldn't sleep at night. I couldn't do the kind of things that Jeff Holland does—lie through his teeth. I can't do it. No wonder the man looks so troubled inside. He's got this conflict going on in his life.
And provided you go by normal mortality ages, he's going to be prophet of the church one day for about eight years, having previously spent a few years as the president of the Quorum of the Twelve under President Oaks. So you've got Oaks and Holland in the pipeline for a significant period.
I couldn't do that. I had to be truthful, and I thought that was the idea—it's the truth church, you just tell the truth. Why am I going on about this? What was the question that I'm answering now?
Scott: What kind of a weapon would you wield as a sniper in the church if you had stayed? I think that was the question.
Tom Phillips: Yeah, I guess that some people would say that's the strategy to adopt.
This church only changes in history when the law has gone after them: polygamy, blacks in the priesthood. Any threat to them—even the touching in the temple was all to do with lawsuits that people were going after them for. So suddenly the naked touching stops. Nothing changes because God gives a revelation to the prophet. It's because the lawmakers say, "You know what? You shouldn't be doing this". And in 1978 you suddenly correct something that the US government had corrected in 1964 in terms of civil rights. Why is the church always behind the curve on these things? You're not getting revelation; it's only legislation.
And hopefully my little contribution here will have some impact on them being a little bit more open and transparent, and certainly a RICO case as well.
Matt Long: What a great summary. What a great way to wrap that up. That was perfect.
Scott: Yep. Thank you, Tom. It's been a pleasure speaking with you.
Tom Phillips: And thank you very much for the opportunity to question. It was a pleasure.
Glenn Ostlund: Tom, could you give us a closing prayer?
The Panel Discussion
Glenn Ostlund: Because you know, you asked the question, Bob, and then Tom's like, "Well, do we want to go through them?" And you're like, "No, we don't really have to, but let's talk about these last two". And then we didn't really talk about them that much.
Bob Caswell: Well, he summarized them all by saying, "Basically, these are the ones that there was objective proof".
Glenn Ostlund: I see.
Bob Caswell: I still don't see the tie between those claims and either the intent to deceive or the tithing thing. You don't have to believe those things to pay tithing.
Scott: There's no connection between those things specifically and tithing. Where the tithing comes in is that the church makes these statements with the goal of gaining financial benefit from them. The fact that the Book of Abraham has nothing to do with whether or not people pay tithing—whether the Book of Abraham is a literal translation of the Egyptian papyri has nothing to do with tithing. But if you believe that, then you're going to pay tithing. That's the only connection for it.
So I think in the first episode we may have overstated the legal relationship with the tithing requirement and these seven points. I think it's important to the case; I think it's important to showing that the church operates differently than other religions, but there has to be a financial component.
Tom said the thing that maybe got overemphasized was that the judge was particularly interested in that aspect—the tithing aspect—which may or may not be ultimately relevant in the long run to the case. It's just that judge was very interested in that.
Glenn Ostlund: But wait a second, that's the whole basis of the fraud! I mean, that's the whole point of the case in the first place, is that the British people—and the British government by extension because of the way the tax structure works over there—has been finagled out of money due to fraudulent activities.
Scott: No, that's part of it. That's not all of it.
Glenn Ostlund: What's the other part?
Scott: The other part is that the people themselves, the members of the church themselves, were—rather, that Thomas Monson dishonestly made a false representation to them with the intent to make a gain for himself or another. The fact that the church basically received British tax money was part of the reason why the case would be in the public good, but it's not a necessary component for the underlying case itself.
Bob Caswell: So, how do you prove his intent?
Scott: There is a—I have to plug this guy's blog because he has probably what I think is the best analysis of it. It's The Positivist, `thepositivists.org`. Got to get a new name, guys: Positivists.
Bob Caswell: They should be Positivists on Thrones.
Scott: It should. That just rolls off the tongue.
Randy Snyder: Well, it's an actual philosophy, so that's why they use that word.
Scott: Oh, Randy, thanks.
Matt Long: Thank you.
Randy Snyder: I'm just saying—as opposed to "infantilism," which is not. I'm just saying it's a well-established philosophical position.
Scott: Are you reading this?
Randy Snyder: No, I'm sitting in the middle of a Wikipedia page. I'm just saying they didn't pick it because it's aesthetic; they picked it because that's their philosophy.
Scott: Okay, so they plugged our podcast, so thank you guys for that. But there's two components of this Fraud Act. A person is in breach of this section if they dishonestly make a false representation. That's the first part. "Dishonestly"—
Bob Caswell: As opposed to honestly making a false representation.
Scott: Well, where you're just mistaken.
Bob Caswell: So it's an honest mistake.
Scott: Right. Dishonestly making a false representation—it's not an honest mistake.
Bob Caswell: Yeah, as opposed to honestly making a false representation. So people say if he really believes all this stuff and he's just telling people what he believes, then that's an honest mistake if these things aren't true but he really believes it.
Matt Long: There's no crime in being wrong.
Scott: There's no crime in being wrong, but it's a little bit more complicated than that. And that's what they talk about in here. The British standard that's noted in this article is called the Ghosh case. What the Ghosh case said was that dishonesty consists of two questions:
1. Was it dishonest according to the ordinary standards of reasonable and honest people?
2. Did he know that he was doing this by those standards dishonestly?
Matt Long: I love that they bring in standards. A reasonable person's standard is really important so that you can't just subjectively say, "Well, I think I was okay". We do this all the time. And I know people out there hate that we are juxtaposing US law with these things. Well, fuck you!
Scott: Wow, it was just one guy!
Matt Long: In US law, one of the things that's critical is whether or not your conduct is reasonable under a reasonable man standard. Even though you may have subjectively believed your life was in danger and therefore you pulled a gun, that doesn't matter. What matters is what a jury would determine under a reasonable man standard—or reasonable woman standard. We here at Infants on Thrones are equal to both our men and women listeners.
Tom Perry: Is a good example of this—and edit this out if this is just out of left field—Gordon B. Hinckley going on Larry King Live and pretending like the church doesn't teach the deification doctrine, when it could be totally shown and displayed in all of their manuals and general conference talks that we absolutely do teach the deification doctrine? Because he wasn't just being mistaken; he was being deceptive. Does that make sense?
Scott: No, I think that makes sense.
Tom Perry: There's a lot of silence, and I was like, "Oh no".
Scott: Let me fill that in a little bit. Again, there's two sets of questions under this Ghosh test:
First, was it done dishonestly according to the ordinary standards of reasonable and honest people? Would a reasonable and honest person look at what President Hinckley did at the time and say, was that dishonest or not?
And if it was dishonest, the second portion is: did he know that he was being dishonest by those standards? Not whether or not he thought it was justified.
The justification aspect is also addressed in this Ghosh case. The analogy that the judge in the Ghosh case drew was what he called the Robin Hood test. He said Robin Hood would have said, "What was wrong about stealing money from the rich and giving it to poor people?" Robin Hood is acting dishonestly even though he may consider himself to be morally justified in what he does, because he knows that ordinary people would consider these actions to be dishonest. So if the church is teaching something that it knows other people would consider to be dishonest, but it thinks it's justified in doing so, that fits the definition of dishonesty.
Bob Caswell: I need an example.
Scott: Okay, so let's talk about the seven points.
Matt Long: The one I thought was number one. But that in and of itself was a good example, wasn't it? Robin Hood or Valjean or whomever—they feel morally justified, but objectively it's a crime. You're still stealing, you have no right to the silver or the bread, and so you've committed a crime even though subjectively you feel justified.
Bob Caswell: I need a Mormon example. My mind is like all Mormon. Robin Hood—has somebody done his temple work for him?
Matt Long: Probably.
Randy Snyder: Probably about 40 or 50 times.
Scott: Okay, let's talk about them.
Number one: that the Book of Abraham is a literal translation of Egyptian papyri by Joseph Smith.
Bob Caswell: Yeah, I love that that's in there. If I was coming up with my own seven, that would definitely be in there because that's pretty easy to show that it's false, and it's still in the freaking scriptures! You wouldn't even have to go to transcripts in the New York library. There are these facsimiles in the Pearl of Great Price. Tom says some of the points require the church to change their scriptures. All we have to do is go to their scriptures, and this is a great example where the church itself has started to formally and informally back off the emphasis.
Matt Long: They've got to do it really slowly. The band-aid can't just be ripped off.
Bob Caswell: With the facsimiles, you've got the footnotes that say what the translations are, which are just stupid. You don't even need to be able to read Egyptian to look at those and go, that can't be what that really says.
Matt Long: And he only needs one, right, Scott?
Scott: At least one, and that one is just far and away the most falsifiable claim that the church makes. It's objectively falsifiable. And it's a core tenet.
Bob Caswell: But with the Book of Abraham, how do you tie that to tithing?
Glenn Ostlund: Exactly.
Bob Caswell: If you play devil's advocate here—and by devil I mean the church—what about the Book of Abraham is required as part of the structural belief related to collecting money from these members?
Randy Snyder: They're canonized.
Bob Caswell: But there are people who pay tithing and go to the temple who have never even heard of the Book of Abraham!
Scott: It doesn't require that the false representation have a direct link to the gain portion. It's just that he dishonestly makes a false representation and intends by making the representation to make a gain for himself.
Bob Caswell: By making the representation that the Book of Mormon is true—even if the Book of Mormon has nothing about tithing in it—you're going to secure tithing dollars by then going three degrees to Kevin Bacon: that there's a prophet on the earth, and the prophet said we need to pay tithing. And this is where I see that it's weak.
Bob made, I thought, a great point when we were talking with Tom Phillips: why not go with the temple recommend questions that link your eternal salvation to the money you've got to pay to play? I just don't see the connection.
Scott: If you make a simple analogy: if I go to my neighbor's house and tell a lie and it's a really compelling story, and then my neighbor thinks I'm a really interesting person who he can trust, and the next day I come and ask for money—they are linked, but it doesn't have to be a material aspect of it. If you say, "Hey, we've got this ancient document that confirms our religion is true," and the document doesn't explicitly mention tithing, and then you say, "Ergo, our religion is true and therefore you should pay us money," I don't see how that's too much of a link for what's required here.
Bob Caswell: Just because it's a long con doesn't make it less of a con.
Scott: Right. The statute is written very broadly to include things like this.
Bob Caswell: But that's where we get into this fuzzy ground, because the definition of religion is a long con, right? Every religion is: you get into heaven later if you do shit today.
Scott: You can use a long con argument because of the tithing structure. You cannot see your kid's wedding if you do not pay tithing. In the Anglican Church, you don't have to pay tithing to go to your kid's wedding.
Bob Caswell: Why do I pay tithing? I pay tithing because this is God's church and God commands it. And why is it God's church? Because there's a prophet on the earth. How do you know there's a prophet? Because of the Book of Mormon, because of revelation, and the Book of Abraham is one of the evidences of that. But the fact that we have to parse it out that roundabout degrees-of-Kevin-Bacon way—it would simplify it if we just picked things that were directly connected.
Scott: Matt, are you looking at this the same way that I am?
Matt Long: I think I'm tracking with you.
Scott: Right, so the two lawyers agree, so we can just move on. We don't need the laypeople's opinion.
Number two: The Book of Mormon was translated from ancient gold plates by Joseph Smith and is the most correct book on earth and is an ancient historical record.
Bob Caswell: This subs out one problem for another because it's closer to a tithing question, but it's like number two A, B, and C.
Scott: Keep in mind that Tom said the judge had rewritten the questions slightly different from what he had submitted, and that was going to be fixed later on. How are they going to falsify this claim? What he's saying here is: A, it was translated from ancient gold plates; B, it's the most correct book on earth; and C, it's an ancient historical record. You could test each one of those.
Matt Long: And more importantly, it goes to President Monson's or the corporation's actual belief in these claims. A defense to this is, "I actually believe this, and here's why". But they're going to have to explain why they either weren't aware of or ignored this other evidence against their position.
Bob Caswell: Is a courtroom obligated to go with scientific consensus, like DNA evidence of Native Americans?
Matt Long: There are standards allowed into court, and one of the principles is that it must be generally accepted in that particular field—there needs to be reliability.
Scott: I think this was back to Tom's point: whether or not it's translated from ancient gold plates, that's not a theological question—that's a historical question. "Most correct book on earth"—I think they should throw that out because that's so ridiculously subjective. But historical record—that's not theological.
Bob Caswell: I sense a level of hesitation here where everyone between the lines is sort of agreeing that this is a harder case to prove compared to the Book of Abraham.
Matt Long: I agree with Scott 100% that if you narrowed it to: "This is a historical record of an ancient people in America from this period of time to this period of time," then there is objective, testable, falsifiable evidence.
Bob Caswell: But can't the same claim be made about the Old Testament—that ancient Hebrews were slaves to Egyptians, where they've found no evidence? There's no evidence that horses, chariots, and steel existed in the Book of Mormon, so we say it's false, but couldn't the same claim be made against the Old Testament?
Scott: What we want is the specificity and the binary aspect of the Book of Abraham, but the applicability of the Book of Mormon. If you're a European on the jury, the Book of Mormon looks at least as ridiculous as the Book of Abraham. And you use the Book of Abraham as evidence of a pattern of fraudulent behavior.
Tom Perry: Is there any wiggle room where the church could use the catalyst theory in a courtroom—saying Joseph Smith used the papyri as a catalyst for inspiration, and then applying that to the Book of Mormon?
Scott: They could make that argument. It's sort of like what happened with the Reed Smoot hearings.
Tom Perry: What year are we talking about for people who aren't familiar with Reed Smoot?
Scott: Around 1904 to 1908. Utah was trying to seat their first LDS senator, Reed Smoot. The church was still practicing post-Manifesto polygamy, and they investigated Mormonism on a public stage. Joseph F. Smith was summoned. They drilled him for days on businesses he owned, his wives, and he had to make major concessions—one of which was basically that he had never received any revelation different from just a normal person praying!
Tom Perry: Which Hinckley said to Larry King, didn't he?
(Glenn inserts transcript note of Larry King interviewing Gordon B. Hinckley about receiving revelation and building the Conference Center)
Scott: Going back to Reed Smoot: because the church was under such public scrutiny, they had to change things. In The Mysteries of Godliness by David John Buerger, they talk about how there used to be a curse box in the temple just like a blessing box! During the Reed Smoot hearings, they found President Buchanan's name had been placed in the curse box in the temple, and they had to stop doing it!
Matt Long: More importantly, it requires them to take hardline positions on things, instead of nailing Jell-O to the wall.
Glenn Ostlund: Let's move on to number three.
Number three: Native Americans are descended from an Israelite family who left Jerusalem in 600 BC.
Bob Caswell: This is the same as number two in my opinion.
Scott: It's different because this is where they bring in Simon Southerton and DNA evidence.
Glenn Ostlund: Remember a couple of years ago when they changed the introduction to the Book of Mormon from saying the Lamanites were the "principal ancestors" to "among the ancestors"?
Scott: The church just put out a recent essay on the DNA issue, so this is actively discussed.
Glenn Ostlund: Number four: Joseph and Hyrum Smith were killed as martyrs in 1844 because they would not deny their testimony of the Book of Mormon.
Bob Caswell: Yeah, that's a total miss. So obscure. Even today, you can call them martyrs for their beliefs, even if they had a pepper-box gun and defended themselves.
Scott: Tom Phillips mentioned that if it were reworded, the word "only" would need to be there—that the only reason they were martyred was the Book of Mormon, whereas they were in Carthage Jail over the destruction of the Nauvoo Expositor.
(Audio clip of Jeffrey R. Holland's General Conference talk holding up the Book of Mormon Hyrum read from in Carthage Jail)
Glenn Ostlund: Number five: The Illinois newspaper called the Nauvoo Expositor had to be destroyed because it printed lies about Joseph Smith.
Bob Caswell: I don't think it's clear that the church centrally teaches that today.
Glenn Ostlund: But Mormon Expression did a whole podcast on that, and even Mike Tannehill conceded at the end that there wasn't a single lie in the Nauvoo Expositor!
Glenn Ostlund: Number six: There was no death on this planet prior to 6,000 years ago.
Bob Caswell: Does the church really take that position?
Scott & Matt Long: Yes, it's in D&C 77 and the Old Testament Student Manual.
Bob Caswell: But the church made an official statement of having no position on evolution. We just had the Dr. Jeff Meldrum podcast!
Scott: Go look at the Old Testament CES manual on Genesis. There's seven pages in there ripping evolution to shreds with the most hardcore Young Earth Creationism you can get, published officially by the church!
Glenn Ostlund: Number seven: All humans alive today are descended from two people who lived approximately 6,000 years ago.
Bob Caswell: Six and seven are essentially the same Young Earth Creationist point.
Prognostications & Tom Phillips's Motivation
Matt Long: What do you guys envision the end result of this being?
Scott: The church ignores it, Monson doesn't show up in March, and they never issue a warrant for his arrest. There's no way they show up for a trial.
Tom Perry: Can we talk about Tom Phillips's motivation? Is he doing this to get compensated, or out of a vendetta?
Glenn Ostlund: I don't think he's trying to change the church. He doesn't give a shit about the church; he's moved on.
Tom Perry: But he is genuinely hurt and severely betrayed. He lost his whole family—his children won't even talk to him!
Glenn Ostlund: I think he's trying to force the conversation. He knows what goes on behind the scenes, and it's not seeing the light of day.
Matt Long: He wants to shine a light and have a public peek behind the curtain at the wizard. He wants to be vindicated—to show that he was right.
Scott: When Mr. Monson does not show up in March, Tom will hammer on the 12th Article of Faith. When international headlines read that a Mormon leader failed to appear for a fraud charge, it's a PR catastrophe.
Bob Caswell: I don't really care about the outcome, but I'm glad he did it. I salute you, Tom Phillips, mate!
Matt Long: He's not Australian!
Bob Caswell: British people said "mate" hundreds of years before Australians did!
Glenn Ostlund: Anyone for the closing prayer?
Retroactive Announcement
Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund. And just real quick, I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.
I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and I'm accepting new clients. So, if you or someone you know is seeking either coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes. So, thanks again for listening, and now here's your episode.
