Ep 50 – The Tom Sigh
Episode 50: The Tom Sigh
Child: "Okay. Okay. You're listening to Infants on Thrones with my dad".
Theme / Intro: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the core.
Introduction: Listener Essay by Jay Briner
Tom Perry: My name is Tom Perry, and welcome to another listener-submitted episode for Infants on Thrones. As you guys and girls know, we've been accepting listener-submitted essays for a while now. What we normally do is play the essay, and then bring the author on for further discussion. When we do this, as loyal listeners know, we try to stay on topic, but oftentimes unrelated tangents come upon us and all hell breaks loose. In my opinion, that's when the true magic happens.
A while back, a listener submitted an essay, and you can imagine my surprise when I saw what he named it:
Jay Briner: "My name is Jay Briner, and the name of my essay is called The Tom Sigh".
Tom Perry: You know, I've gotten a lot of crap for this in the past. If my memory serves, someone created an actual drinking game for Mormon-themed podcasts, and my sigh was in the top ten. Can you imagine knowing that someone was taking a shot after each of my audible sighs on past podcasts?
Some speculated that I used the "Tom Sigh" when I was disgusted by an extreme or ridiculous example. Some said I used it when someone attacked the church or its believers. Some thought I used it when someone attempted a lame joke, or that I was just tired of the discussion. I felt like now is a good time to put this mystery to bed once and for all: the answer is, yep, all of the above!
I sigh out loud when participating in podcasts, or even when listening to podcasts with my earbuds in. If you run into me while I have my Skullcandies in, there is a good chance you'll hear me sigh live, or say, "Oh, come on," "Oh, brother," or "Oh, right on, dude!"
Back to Jay's essay: we don't spend time talking about me or my sigh, which is a relief. He uses it as a metaphor. As a disclaimer, this recording is our second attempt because our first attempt had technical issues on my end. I want to publicly thank Jay for sitting down a second time to hash out ex-Mormons, communities, believers, and family transitions.
Jay's Essay: The Tom Sigh as an Auditory Landmark
Jay Briner (Essay): After my faith crisis, like many of you, I really came to appreciate all the hard work people spent producing Mormon-themed podcasts. It helped me not feel crazy. Out of all the things I could relate to, one of the auditory landmarks I identified with most was the Tom Sigh.
Somebody on Mormon Expression would say something snarky or sharp, and then Tom would sigh. Depending on how the conversation was going, people would either be irritated by Tom's sigh or laugh at it.
I had a great experience growing up in Mormonism. My parents fall well within the bell curve of great parents. My extended family is full of people you are proud to know; their goodness is not an act. My mission president was a great guy who didn't subject missionaries to psychological torture. At BYU, I had classy roommates. In my profession, facilities management, BYU graduates are generally much better than non-BYU graduates.
I say this as a full-fledged apostate: the corporation and I are finished, but Mormons are the salt of the earth.
Both of my grandfathers were chemists, both grandmothers were teachers, and all four earned bachelor's degrees. My mom's dad consecrated his life to the LDS corporate benefit. He was head chemist at the assay office in Murray, Utah, under the giant smokestack where Costco is now. He had 30 chemists working under him, was respected in the community, raised millions for the Boy Scouts, and served on the local hospital board.
When hospital nurses went on strike, Grandpa was in the negotiations and said, "I think we should give the nurses what they're asking for. We've got the money. It's worth it". The nurses got their raise and the strike ended.
Grandpa was stake president at the time and helped build the Murray 3rd Ward meetinghouse behind the BMW dealership off State Street. He led construction crews after work and even announced at stake conference that he wouldn't shave his beard until the building was funded.
I got 25% of my DNA from each of those four grandparents—100% of my DNA comes from devout Mormons. I'm proud of that DNA.
So when Tom is sighing on those podcasts, I'm sighing right along with him. When I think of Mormons, these are the people I think of. They are totally fine exactly the way they are; they don't need to change to be okay with me.
At the same time, I am finished with the LDS Corporation. I see the corporation as an extension of Joseph Smith's marital vows: like a lying, cheating spouse who expects 100% fidelity from the faithful partner, but doesn't deliver fidelity or honesty in return.
It's this tension I hear in Tom's sigh. On one hand, we hold high regard for these wonderful people in our lives. On the other hand, when we blow the whistle on the corporation, it changes our relationship with them, and that's painful and unfair.
The corporation has poisoned the well about people like us—saying we're under Satan's power, covenant breakers, offended, or sinning. The antidote to that corporate poison is sunlight: being who you are out in the open. It's okay for true-believing friends and family to be who they are, and it's okay for us apostates to be who we are.
Recovered Audio Clips: The Dualist Reality
Tom Perry: Before getting into our live discussion, here are two clips from the recovered audio of our first attempt:
Jay Briner (Clip 1): When listening to podcasts, I'd imagine if my wife were in the room while she was still a believer, and how certain parts would have offended her. If I had been on the podcast, I would have sighed, too. I never lost respect for believers in my life. It's not like I realized the church was false and suddenly hated all these people. If I reject Mormonism, do I have to reject my grandpa? No, I don't have to reject anybody.
Jay Briner (Clip 2): What kicked this off was listening to the podcast slugfest between Dan Wotherspoon and Brian Dalton (Mr. Deity). They were duking it out for an hour like a verbal MMA match. Then you get to the part where Dalton says: "If I could pick my neighbors, I'd pick Mormons". In 27 years in the church, I don't think I ever met a racist; Mormons are some of the best people on the planet. Even outspoken critics have this: whenever Randy talks about his dad, he says, "No, I love my dad," and John Larson makes space for doubters without having a personal beef with individual Mormons.
Discussion: The Corporation vs. The People
Tom Perry: You make a clear point to separate criticism of the organization from individuals. When beliefs are criticized, people take it personally.
Jay Briner: When I talk about the church online or in writing, I don't even refer to it as the church—I call it "the corporation". But when I talk about Mormons, it's almost always in positive terms.
Tom Perry: Do you still find yourself freaking out over weird Mormon news, like Thomas S. Monson getting summoned to court in Britain?
Jay Briner: No, I'm over that. Tom Phillips did that on his own without a committee, and we don't know if it's going anywhere, so let's wait and see. When I said "freak out," I meant that early fear of losing my family, divorce, or intense anger at feeling misled. For two years, if anyone asked, I said I was over the anger, but that wasn't true. It took at least two and a half years and several months of counseling to get out of that emotional pain.
Tom Perry: I've been through counseling, too, and strongly recommend finding a therapist who works with you. In your essay, you mentioned that being Mormon is an automatic point in someone's favor when hiring.
Jay Briner: Generally, yes. In facilities management, BYU has the best program in the country—your options are hiring an expensive engineer, a BYU grad, or someone unqualified. On the bell curve of acceptable humans, Mormons tend to land on the good side.
Missions: Phoenix vs. Peoria
Tom Perry: You served a mission in Phoenix?
Jay Briner: Yes, and my mission president was a university administrator who worked with college kids his entire career. In interviews, when missionaries said they felt unworthy because they listened to unapproved music, he told them: "Bring the CD into your interview at zone conference, and I'll either approve it or I won't". And he approved every single one! He recognized it wasn't worth feeling crappy over.
Tom Perry: That's amazing. I went to Peoria, Illinois—meth labs and Caterpillar factories! I served in Burlington, Iowa; Kirksville, Missouri; Springfield; and Decatur. I had great companions, but my mission president was heavily into mission politics.
The Infidelity Metaphor & "Trickle Truth"
Tom Perry: Let's look at your comparison of the church to a cheating spouse. That raises eyebrows.
Jay Briner: Go to any forum where people discuss marital infidelity. They trusted their spouse, were completely caught off guard, felt violated, and the spouse demanded 100% loyalty while lying behind their back, taking their money, and blaming them for everything.
The church has known about these historical issues for 150 years. In infidelity, there's a concept called trickle truth: a spouse admits they had dinner with a secretary, weeks later admits they kissed in the car, and months later it comes out they were meeting in hotels for six months.
That's what these anonymous Gospel Topics essays on lds.org are doing—dribbling the truth out bit by bit without date stamps, timestamps, or authors. Missionaries teach that families can be together forever, but don't mention Joseph Smith marrying 33 women, including 14-year-olds and women whose husbands were sent away on missions! If you told investigators the whole truth upfront, nobody would hand their life over to the corporation.
Closet Doubters and Creating Safe Harbors
Tom Perry: Would you ever bring these essays up to your grandpa if he were alive?
Jay Briner: No. He lived a full life, raised great kids, paid his mortgage, and was happy. Why would I mess with that? If a neighbor were a happy Catholic, I wouldn't try to plant seeds to ruin their faith, so why do it to Mormon family?
What I do want is to be out of the closet enough so that if a cousin or nephew experiences disaffection, they don't feel crazy and alone.
I know a prominent LDS family where the youngest child is a secret non-believer, while an older sibling is a strident online apologist. It must be terrible to feel completely isolated in your own home. If ex-Mormons are open, the social cost of leaving becomes lower for the next person.
Tom Perry: When you went through your faith crisis, who did you turn to?
Jay Briner: In my extended family, everyone was true-blue. Immaturely, I scrolled through Facebook and messaged LDS friends who had alcohol in their photos, asking if they had left the church! They didn't reply at first because they thought I was going to judge them. Podcasts like John Dehlin's Mormon Stories and Mormon Expression helped me realize I wasn't crazy.
The Pendulum: Fundamentalism vs. Liberal Mormonism
Tom Perry: Growing up, whenever I felt like watching an R-rated movie or golfing on Sunday, I was overwhelmed with guilt. My priest adviser grabbed my arm at church when I tried to leave early for golf, shook his head, and made me feel so terrible that I stayed.
Jay Briner: That's the pendulum:
1. Fundamentalism: You take everything literally. But your brain gets exhausted trying to justify things that are obviously false—like a literal global Noah's flood or God changing skin color as a punishment.
2. Liberal Mormonism: The pendulum swings over. You treat difficult stories as allegories and metaphors. That feels great until you realize you can make scripture say whatever you want, so you swing back to fundamentalism out of guilt.
Eventually, the pendulum snaps off the ceiling, crashes down, and you're in a full faith crisis.
The Marker of Emotional Healing
Jay Briner: When people leave, they often adopt the same missionary zeal in reverse—wanting to run into the chapel and shout, "This is all fake, who's coming with me?!" I was that guy blurting out the Jupiter talisman to my home teachers while my wife looked at me like I was insane.
The real marker of emotional healing is when you can talk to active Mormons, listen to them talk about the Book of Abraham, and not take the bait. You reach indifference and let people be who they are.
Tom Perry: What was the turning point for you to finally walk away?
Jay Briner: Two and a half years ago, my son turned eight. My brother had mentioned something slightly heterodox during a mission interview, and the bishop called me in, suspecting I had influenced him. As a result, I wasn't allowed to baptize my eight-year-old son. The bishop suggested waiting a few months, but I said no—my dad came and baptized him so my kid wouldn't feel alienated as the only unbaptized kid in Primary. That was the moment I knew I was done.
Jay Briner: Anyone for the closing prayer? If any of you are playing that drinking game, you're probably drunk by now!
Retroactive Announcement
Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund. Just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.
I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and accepting new clients. So if you or someone you know is seeking either coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes. Thanks again for listening.
