Ep 40 – Bednar, Bear Hugs, and Brainwashing
Episode 40: Bednar, Bear Hugs, and Brainwashing
David A. Bednar (Audio Clip): "This morning I want to discuss some of the spiritual lessons we can learn from the process by which a cucumber becomes a pickle. Pickle. I invite the Holy Ghost to be with us as we consider the significance of those lessons for me and for you... A pickle is a cucumber that has been transformed according to a specific recipe and series of steps. The first steps in the process of changing a cucumber into a pickle are..."
(Music: "We Will Rock You")
Child: "Infants on Thrones with my dad."
Theme / Intro: This is Infants on Thrones. Philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the core of the core.
Introduction: Lindsay's Letter
Glenn: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones, where pickles are made from cucumbers 365 days a year. I'm Glenn Ostlund, and we'll be hearing more from the illustrious Elder Bednar later in the episode. But first, we start with Bob reading a question we received from a listener named Lindsay. Lindsay has a 9-year-old son and is wondering what will happen when he turns 12. She wants to hear us talk about what it's like to be a young man in the priesthood. Today we have myself along with Bob Caswell, Randy Snyder, Tom Perry, Matt Long, and a special appearance from Matt's 14-year-old son. Take it away, Bob.
Bob: Here we go:
"Thanks for all you guys do for the podcast. I love listening. One thing that came up last week was something I thought might be a good topic, so I thought I'd pass it along. My 9-year-old son is very much a thinker. He doesn't believe in the literalness of Mormonism, nor does he believe in a Heavenly Father. He is reading Richard Dawkins' book, The Magic of Reality, and loves it. But because my husband really values the community of Mormonism and is somewhat figuring out his own faith journey, our family continues to attend church in order to keep the family together. I tried leaving a few years ago, and it just started taking our marriage in a direction I didn't want to go.
Anyway, back to my 9-year-old son. Doesn't buy Mormonism. Talks to me a lot, asks why, many questions. We have great discussions; I'm grateful. Last week, though, he asked me if he will have to pass the sacrament when he turns 12. That was something I had never thought of before. He said he really doesn't want to pass the sacrament, and he doesn't want to serve a mission. And I got to thinking about all the other things that are expected of these boys once they turn 12: priesthood, home teaching, fast offerings, sacrament prep, sacrament passing, blessing, missions. What happens to these boys if they politely decline to participate in any or all of these things? Is that an option? Because I'm not a man, I really don't know how to help prepare my son for Young Men and the issues he may face. This is all assuming that we'll still be attending. Hopefully my husband will see the light before we have to really deal with this. If you guys have thoughts, I'd love to hear them".
Bob: My first thought is there's not going to be an easy middle road. I don't have kids, but I remember being 12 in the church. When someone didn't participate, it was weird for him, and it was weird for us. Let's bring in Matt's son, Tommy.
Interview with 14-Year-Old Tommy
Matt: Tommy is 14 now. At one point he was 12 and anxious to get the priesthood and pass the sacrament. He doesn't know the topic, but you can ask him how he felt and how he transitioned out.
Glenn: Hi, Tommy. When you were 12 years old, describe where you were in your belief.
Tommy: I just kind of followed along because I was brainwashed all that time.
Glenn: How do you know you're not brainwashed now, Tommy?
Tommy: Because we looked into stuff, I guess.
Glenn: But when you were 12, you were a believer in that moment?
Tommy: Right. It was something new, so it was like, "Oh, now I get to walk around in that quiet time and not be all bored".
Bob: When you started to move away from belief as a family, did you notice a change in how people treated you? Were you left out of the main scene?
Tommy: I didn't really care. In my ward, the only guy my age was this total nerdy kid who stunk and had BO, and I didn't want to be next to him anyway. And I had two other friends a year older who didn't care.
Glenn: Do you have Mormon friends at school?
Tommy: I do. I have some extreme Mormon friends, and then I have cool Mormons. Extreme Mormons shove their religion down your throat and get annoying, telling you to go to church every single Sunday. The cool Mormons believe, but they don't care what you do because it's not their life.
Glenn: What were your Young Men leaders like?
Tommy: Not cool at all. They were almost like that smelly kid my age, but 40. The smelly kid with authority. Once we left, I just stopped doing Scouts and all that because it was boring.
Glenn: What did you think when your mom and dad started looking into stuff?
Tommy: They asked questions like, "Do you think this is true?" or "How else could you look at this?" When you looked into it more, it made more sense that it wasn't true than that it was true.
Bob: So Lindsay's son is 9, and she's wondering if he'll face peer pressure or if it will be scary when he turns 12 and doesn't want to pass the sacrament. Did you experience that?
Tommy: When the bishop calls you in to talk about whether you want to do it, it was scary because I was little and it's a big guy with authority talking to you. It was a little pressure, but back then I just went with the flow and did what everybody else was doing.
Glenn: Thanks, Tommy.
Matt: See? You can continue to brainwash your children even when you leave the church! In retrospect, passing the sacrament was exciting for him the first couple of times because of the attention, but then it just became boring.
Navigating Priesthood Expectations & Stewardship
Randy: Tommy didn't have intense social pressure because his leaders weren't close friends and his peer group was outside the ward. But Lindsay's son is in a different boat: his dad wants to participate, and his leaders are going to push hard. When I was a Scoutmaster and Young Men counselor, we put tons of pressure on kids whose parents were inactive or ambivalent. If the mom is holding back and the dad is pushing, leaders will view that as an open license to intervene.
Bob: In situations where one spouse believes and the other doesn't, can parents just let the kid decide?
Glenn: Leaders take their "stewardship" over youth very seriously. When they see a parent disengaging, they feel a divine duty to step in and save that boy.
Matt: You have to set boundaries. I had a very loving bishop tell me, "You understand I have responsibility over your family". I looked at him and said the day he crosses the line with my family is the last day he ever sees us. Lindsay might not be in a position to say that, but parents must establish ground rules: no one-on-one interviews with children behind closed doors. Empower the child. Tell him, "If a leader asks you something you aren't comfortable with, tell them: 'My mom told me not to talk about this alone; go talk to my parents'". That takes the burden off the child.
Randy: For passing the sacrament, reframe it: you're providing a service. The bread needs to get to the congregation, and doing it makes his dad happy without validating the supernatural doctrine. And regarding a mission: he's nine! Tell him he doesn't have to make that decision today. Once he turns 18 and heads off to college, he's on his own.
Tom: Build a strong rapport with your son. Take him out for ice cream, have open conversations, and be a safe harbor so that when things get weird at church, he knows he can talk to you. My big concern is that a leader tries to step in as a "surrogate spiritual father" to fill the gap. That's what happened to me growing up—a dedicated adviser and seminary teacher were what pushed me onto a mission.
Elder Bednar's Line in the Rug: Bear Hugs and Fear
Glenn: Speaking of leaders who won't take no for an answer, let's talk about David A. Bednar's recent youth fireside.
Bob: It was in a town hall format with Bednar walking around in immaculate, spit-shined shoes, commanding total awe. A 12-year-old boy asked: "If you stop reading the scriptures, what is the best way to get back into reading them?"
Randy: And Bednar turned that poor kid into an object lesson on the spot!
Glenn: He walked the boy over to the edge of a carpet. "Do you see the end of this rug? Over here is the Lord's territory, and over there is the devil's territory". He has the kid walk deeper into the rug: "When you read your scriptures and pray, you take steps deeper into the Lord's territory and turn your back on the devil".
Tom: Then Bednar walks him backward: "Now you stop praying for a day, you stop reading for a week, and you're rotten to your siblings. Now you're right on the edge of the rug".
Glenn: He pushes the kid across the line into the "devil's territory" and says, "Try to get back across". The kid tries, and Bednar grabs him in a full bear hug from behind! He says, "For an old man, I'm pretty strong, huh? You can't move because you've lost control. I am roleplaying the devil in this experiment".
Matt: The poor kid broke down crying! It was completely manipulative. At no point in the entire demonstration was the Atonement mentioned! There was no room for repentance or grace. It taught that if you slip up, you are instantly trapped in Satan's power.
Glenn: My 13-year-old daughter watched the clip and said, "Even if you're reading scriptures and praying every day, you could still make mistakes or commit murder, but you think you're safe just because you checked the boxes". Teenagers see right through that black-and-white fearmongering.
Tom: If that were my son up there crying, I'd run down the aisle, shove Bednar away, and say, "Get the hell away from my son! What are you doing?"
The Pickle Metaphor & Closing Thoughts
Glenn: Let's finish with Elder Bednar's pickle analogy:
David A. Bednar (Audio Clip): "I remember many hours spent on the back porch of my home removing stems from and scrubbing dirt off of the cucumbers we had picked. My mom was very particular about the preparing and cleaning of the cucumbers. The next steps in this process of change are immersing and saturating the cucumbers in salt brine for an extended period of time. Cucumbers can only become pickles if they are totally and completely immersed in the brine for the prescribed time..."
Glenn: You're either a cucumber or a pickle—there's no in-between!
Retroactive Announcement
Glenn: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund. Just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.
I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and accepting new clients. So if you or someone you know is seeking either coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes. Thanks again for listening.
