Ep 35 – Marriage

Glenn and Tom talk to Mike and Olivia about Marriage when one spouse is a believer and the other is not. Matt and his wife Kristin also drop in to share some experiences of their own.

Episode 35: Marriage

Princess Bride / Wedding Clip: "Mawwiage. Mawwiage is what bwings us togethew today. That dweam within a dweam..."

Child: "Okay. Okay. You're listening to Infants on Thrones with my dad".

Theme / Intro: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the core.

Introduction: The Believing Spouse Dilemma

Glenn: Well, sort of. Let me read you an email that I got on Facebook about a week ago:
"Do any of you guys in the quorum have wives that are still believers? My husband is a liberal believer, but he has potential. Personally, I think he's procrastinating the day of reckoning when he takes a hard look at it all. Anyway, I'm wondering if any of you have had to deal with a believing spouse? Would love to hear experiences and tips for helping our spouses understand us".

Well, you know, I think there's probably podcasts out there that do a better job of this than we would. But I thought this could be an opportunity to bring back one of my favorite new people, Mike L, who you may remember from the Secrets of Abraham podcast. I didn't get a chance to talk to him because I was out of town when Tom recorded that, so I thought: why not contact Mike and see if he and his wife Olivia want to come on and talk about their experience? Not only was he a non-believer while she was a believer, but she wasn't a member when they first started dating; he played a role in her conversion, and then eventually played a role in her deconversion.

At the same time, Matt and his wife Kristen decided to jump on and talk about their experience, and we have Tom as well talking about his experience with his wife. So that's what you have in store for you today on Infants on Thrones with me, Glenn Ostlund, and our co-host Tom.

Olivia's Host Quiz

Glenn: Now, before dispensing any of our ever-so-wise and ever-so-profound infantile marriage advice, Olivia prepared a special treat for Tom and me: a listener survey designed just for us.

Tom: Is it multiple choice, or are there essays?

Olivia: There's one essay, and then there's some multiple choice.

Glenn: Olivia, what would you think about reading those questions to Tom and me, and we'll just answer them right here?

Olivia: All right. Question 1: What do you think your listeners really think about your podcast?
A) That it's awesome, because it is.
B) That they are obsessed with the podcast and need to get a life.
C) That they like it in an appropriate, healthy way.
D) They don't like it, but they tell us they do because they don't want to hurt us the way the church hurt them.

Tom: I would probably say C—they like it in an appropriate, healthy way. I want to answer A, but that makes me sound like a narcissist.

Glenn: It didn't stop me! A is my answer. I thought for sure you were going to go with D, but that's me projecting the Eeyore onto you.

Olivia: Okay, Question 2: Are there any podcast guests that you wish you never had on the podcast?
A) Yes, Christa.

Tom: And that's the only option you gave us!

Olivia: I couldn't not!

Glenn: Come on, really? You hated Christa that much?

Olivia: I cringed through the entire thing on every one of them! And I still listened to the entire thing anyway—one of them I listened to twice, because I enjoy cringing so much. It brought me back to testimony meetings where people get up and start talking about their vacations and spouting off things that aren't appropriate in front of the sacrament.

Tom: I still have fingernail marks in my palms from cringing so hard!

Glenn: The channeling one in Part 3 was polarizing. But it opens up weird areas of exploration: if you were actually sitting across from Emma Smith, what would she say? I've got hours of recorded stuff with her that I haven't done anything with because the response has been so polarizing. Like when Brother Jake and his wife Erica were over talking to her, and Jake got into future sci-fi questions about whether artificial intelligence could fuse with a soul and become a living thing!

Olivia: This next question was Mike's idea. Question 3: Do you have a two-year supply of food?
A) Yes, it's wise counsel.
B) If alcohol counts as food, then yes.
C) No, that is weird and hoarderish.
D) I have less than two years' worth, but more than two days' worth.
E) Yes, and if you ever find it, I will kill you, salt killer you, and add you to it. Survivalism, bitch!

Tom: Definitely E! I have a 72-hour kit, but it's probably expired.

Olivia: The other day we needed canned goods for a discount donation; Mike was down in our food storage for five minutes and couldn't find a single can that wasn't expired by three years! We have stuff going back to 2008. If you want botulism, we're good for a long time.

Olivia: Last question: How often do you dream about the podcast?
A) Every once in a while.
B) Never.
C) Never, but I probably will start to now—thanks a lot.
D) I'm working this out with my therapist.

Tom: I would choose B, but a little bit of C. Early in the Mormon Expression days it entered my psyche a lot more, but now I have much healthier boundaries.

Mike and Olivia: The Long Game & The Logic Class

Glenn: Let's get to our main discussion. The listener email asked how to cope when your spouse is in a different place, and how to get them to understand us. Mike, in your essay, you mentioned that you faked it for years while Olivia was fully believing, and then eventually she came around. Tell us your story from both perspectives.

Mike: As far as deconversion stories go, ours is fairly unique. I was fully faithful and faking it to the very end. I never went inactive. I spent as much time in nursery and primary as I could so I wouldn't have to sit in elders quorum, and I served as ward clerk. I played the part because we had seen good friends go through ugly divorces when one spouse stopped believing and became vocal about it.

Olivia: I had no idea what Mike was thinking. Looking back, he was very smart about testing the waters. When he got a new job, he'd say, "My new boss goes to an evangelical church and he's the nicest guy—it's so weird, you normally think only Mormons are nice, but he's awesome". Or in college, an evangelical friend gave him a couple of books critical of Mormonism. Mike brought them home and said, "This guy said I should read these—what do you think?" I read one paragraph, got horrified, and said, "This is horrible, I can't handle this"—and Mike immediately backed off.

Mike: A couple of years ago, I got a little braver and said, "Can you believe they left the Book of Abraham in the Pearl of Great Price?"

Glenn: Olivia, when he put that bait out, how long did it take for him to reel you in?

Olivia: See, that's the thing: it wasn't him! It really wasn't. What caused my deconversion was that I took a logic course in college. As part of my degree, I had to take a philosophy requirement, so I chose formal logic. I learned how to think. I learned that starting with a conclusion and working backwards to justify it is completely unreasonable. And I realized that's exactly what I had done with Mormonism: I started with the conclusion that this was true, and anything that didn't fit in that box, I shoved out and buried. Once I allowed myself to think rationally and get fed up with things in the church, I was ready when Mike tested the waters again.

Mike: That was around September or October. Then in December, we were laying in bed and she just turned to me and said, "You know, I have some real problems with the church, and here they are". I had been hiding my doubts for six or seven years, she had been processing hers for months, and it just took one person being brave enough to speak up.

Matt and Kristen: The Apologist Phase & Household Negotiations

Glenn: Matt and Kristen, how did this play out in your marriage?

Kristen: A lot of what Olivia said resonated with me. Matt was a youth Sunday School teacher for five years, and every week while preparing lessons he would get angry about how the manual always forced everything back to "follow the prophet" or temple attendance. He would bring books home about Joseph Smith, and I would tell him, "Don't read those!"

For a long time, I became the apologist: "Who cares if it's all true? It's good". But then Matt had me read about Joseph Smith's polygamy, polyandry, and his affairs behind Emma's back. That's when I finally said, "Man, I don't believe this". I grew up in an active Mormon family where four of my siblings served missions and I didn't, so it's easy for family to say I never had a testimony. But I just realized it wasn't true.

Matt: We've always been liberal Mormons—we drank Coke, watched R-rated movies, and went out on Sundays. Early on, I learned not to proselytize to my wife. I would express my frustration and then stop, dropping breadcrumbs and letting her process it on her own time. When I stopped believing, I still went to sacrament meeting to support her, but then I'd slip out early to watch football. And because she supported me in leaving early, I made sure to fold laundry, cook dinner, and clean the house so she felt supported, too. Over months, she'd come home from church increasingly frustrated by the things being said over the pulpit, until the lightbulb went off for her, too.

Olivia's Conversion & The Priesthood Gap

Olivia: To understand our dynamic, you have to know that I wasn't raised religious. In middle school I met Mike, and when he moved away, I started attending an evangelical church. When he moved back, I went to church dances with him. A mutual friend told me, "It's too bad you aren't Mormon, because Mormons only marry Mormons".

Then after we were engaged, we visited Mike's family. They were playing board games and suddenly started singing a Primary song—"Families Can Be Together Forever"—in gorgeous, four-part harmony. I had chills. They were so close and happy, and I thought, "I want this for my family—this is the way".

Glenn: Did you know when you were baptized that you could become a god?

Olivia: Mike actually explained that to me before I joined! I asked how there could be more than one God, and he said, "Do you believe in aliens? Do you think aliens have the same God or an alien Jesus? They'd have a different God!"

Glenn: When Gordon B. Hinckley went on national television and said, "I don't know that we teach that," it bummed me out—he took away my favorite doctrine!

Olivia: But once we were married, conflict arose because every week in Relief Society and Young Women's, I was told the husband holds the priesthood and is supposed to be the spiritual leader of the home. Mike was in the nursery, mentally exhausted, and had stopped leading family home evening, scriptures, and family prayer. I didn't resent him, but I felt disappointed that our kids weren't seeing the priesthood leadership the church told me they should expect. Before joining, I had asked why women couldn't hold the priesthood, and here Mike had this sacred privilege and wasn't even using it!

Tom's Story: The Tithing Cliff & The Turning Point

Tom: My experience was the exact opposite of Mike's. I kept my wife informed at every stage of my faith crisis, and it was rocky. There were two moments where the tide turned hard:
1. When I looked her in the eyes and told her I no longer believed the church was what it claimed to be. Walls immediately went up between us personally and intimately.
2. When I told her, "I am not going to pay tithing anymore". That was the icing on the cake. She felt that as long as I paid tithing, I could come back; stopping tithing meant the reality set in that our eternal marriage was being downgraded to "until death do you part".

I was constantly on the computer at the library reading MormonThink, New Order Mormon, and apologetics. She'd ask if I was chatting with some hottie, and I'd show her historical research on the Mountain Meadows Massacre. Her eyes would glaze over: "That happened 150 years ago—who cares?" I kept pushing and force-feeding her.

The turning point came when she got pregnant right after I was released from the high council and stopped attending. She broke down, terrified of what the future held. I finally realized: I've been a dick for months. This church means the world to her socially and spiritually. I need to meet her halfway.

I agreed to go back to church with her and took a calling. I completely stopped harping on the church. And because I showed her that my love for her was bigger than my objections to the church, she reciprocated. Within a year, she told me, "If you don't want to come to church every week, that's fine—you don't have to". Now she doesn't even ask me to go.

Respect and the Marriage Covenant

Glenn: Did respect ever become an issue? When someone dismisses Mountain Meadows or doesn't measure up to priesthood standards, does mutual respect erode?

Tom: Honestly, yes. When I did due diligence reading multiple books on Mountain Meadows and she completely dismissed it, I lost respect for her. But I was an arrogant asshole who wasn't giving her space.

Olivia: I never lost respect for Mike. I knew he was his own person. When we prayed about decisions, he'd say, "I didn't get an answer," while I'd feel good about something, so I just assumed he was letting me lead because I was more spiritual.

Glenn: In my first marriage, respect was definitely an issue. Getting ready for church on Sunday mornings was an absolute nightmare of screaming and tension, and when I suggested finding a way to have peace in the home, it was rejected. We saw five different marriage therapists over four years. The LDS Social Services therapist was totally worthless, and when we saw a secular therapist, my ex-wife didn't trust her because she suspected she was a lesbian who didn't share our values.

When I was a student at BYU, I believed that if God commanded polygamy, you had to accept it—petty human emotions like jealousy wouldn't exist in the celestial law of "celestial free love"! When my ex-wife said Joseph Smith made polygamy up, I was shocked that she could even call herself a Mormon!

Olivia: In Mormonism, the marriage covenant isn't just a legal agreement—it's a temple promise of eternity. When one person stops believing, the other feels that the eternal foundation of their future has been shattered.

Outlets and Loneliness

Glenn: Mike, what was your outlet during those years of silence?

Mike: I didn't have one, and that was the biggest problem. In nursery, I was happy playing with three-year-olds. The day I was released from nursery and made ward clerk, I literally cried because I knew my sanctuary was gone. I spent two years severely depressed, sitting in my car during lunch breaks, feeling like I couldn't talk to a single soul—not even my wife.

Tom: That's why anonymous message boards like New Order Mormon and podcasting were literal lifesavers. They gave us an outlet so we didn't have to unload all that heavy processing onto our spouses.

Final Takeaways and Advice

Mike: To the listener who wrote in: put your marriage and your family first, and the church second. I was willing to fake it for the rest of my life if it meant keeping my family together. Every relationship is different, but keep marital harmony at the forefront.

Tom: If your need to be understood is weighing heavy on your heart, stop trying to force your spouse to understand you. Instead, take off your shoes, step into theirs, and seek to understand them first. Give them room. When I stopped preloading podcasts onto my wife's MP3 player and backed off completely, she came to me on her own and said, "Hey, I listened to your interview with Will Bagley". That mutual respect took time, but it saved our marriage.

Post-Show Easter Egg: Randy's Hypnagogic Demons

Randy: I had an awesome hypnagogic hallucination recently! I was lying in bed, paralyzed, and a supernatural demon entered the room. Clear as day, the thought went through my head: "Oh my god, the paranormal is real! I have to be intellectually consistent and abandon my atheism!" And then I snapped out of it and laughed so hard.

Tom: Can you have morning wood when you're paralyzed like that?

Randy: Dude, I'm scared shitless! But hey, I've got total gay attraction to demons—they're the hot bad boys you just want to change!

Retroactive Announcement

Glenn: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund. Just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.

I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and accepting new clients. So if you or someone you know is seeking coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes. Thanks again for listening.

Ep 35 – Marriage
Broadcast by