Ep 34 – Damned Liberals

Are liberal Mormons good or bad for the Church? What kind of Mormon Church do the infant panelists want to see 20 years from now? In this episode Tom, Glenn, Bob, Jesse, and Randy try to answer these questions along with many more. See below for links to content discussed and shared. Sam Harris Seminar – The View from the End of the World: http://longnow.org/seminars/02005/dec/09/the-view-from-the-end-of-the-world/ Joni Hilton’s removed “Are you a liberal Mormon?” Meridian Article: https://archive.org/stream/MeridianMagazineAreYouALiberalMormonMeridianMagazineLDSMormonAndLatterDaySaintNewsAndViews/Meridian-Magazine-Are-You-a-Liberal-Mormon-Meridian-Magazine-LDS-Mormon-and-Latter-day-Saint-News-and-Views#page/n0/mode/2up Nine Inch Nails – Find My Way: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00EQNYTK4/ref=dm_mu_dp_trk4

Episode 34: Damned Liberals

Child: "Okay. Okay. You're listening to Infants on Thrones with my dad".

Theme / Intro: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the core.

Introduction: Joanie Hilton's Article

Tom Perry: Hey everybody, my name's Tom Perry. And in today's episode, we want to talk about liberal Mormons, uncorrelated Mormons, cafeteria Mormons, New Order Mormons—you get the drift. There's like a hundred and something adjectives for this label called liberal Mormons or flexible Mormons. Today's episode was originally inspired by an article published in Meridian Magazine around Halloween 2013, authored by Joanie Hilton, titled "Are You a Liberal Mormon?" It caused quite a bit of a stir and got pulled from the Meridian website. Since it's very short, I'm going to read it so you can understand the emotions and reaction it caused.

Reading: "Are You a Liberal Mormon?" by Joanie Hilton (October 31, 2013)

Tom (reading excerpt):
"Long before the word liberal found its way into politics, it simply meant broad-minded. Liberal thinkers were open to change and progress, a bit resistant to traditional ways and dogmas, and considered themselves a tad more intellectual than the stodgy folks who preferred the status quo. Liberal folks fancied themselves less judgmental, more accepting, and more inclusive. Liberal people had been to Europe and let you know it. They had continental taste, exposure to the latest fashions, and eagerly embraced whatever was new and exciting. They were the daring crowd, the ones who were unafraid to live life on the edge. Bohemians, freethinkers, beatniks, hippies—all prided themselves on being open to take risks and throw off convention.

I think I was a child when I first heard the term 'liberal Mormon'. It meant people who were of our faith, but who drew their own lines in the sand. They decided which aspects of our faith to accept or reject, from honoring the Sabbath to wearing less than modest clothing. Basically, it described people who were members of convenience. When they didn't like something the prophet said, they felt perfectly fine skirting around that one and writing their own rules.

'Jack Mormon' is a similar phrase usually applied to people who don't obey our rules, particularly Word of Wisdom rules, or who consider themselves Mormon but never attend church. Jack Mormons are obvious about it, too: you see them staggering out of a bar or heading into a shopping mall on Sundays. Liberal Mormons are more slippery. They often attend church, but they're the ones who dodge Gospel Doctrine class because the teacher is, quote, 'so by the book'. This criticism is meant to imply that he's a dolt who never questions anything. 'So why should I attend a class taught by someone so narrow-minded?'

They disagree with several points in the Proclamation to the World, say no to callings that insult their intelligence, and create their own spin on how God will ultimately judge us very leniently. Usually, they think bikinis are fine, iced tea is a tasty drink, and R-rated movies are often artistic and worth seeing. Invariably, liberal Mormons do not read their scriptures every day. They do not attend the temple. They do not show up to help someone move. And they do not home teach or visit teach with regularity. They view those who do as quaint minions who never question authority and follow the rules like mindless sheep.

The one thing they do subscribe to with gusto, however, is free agency. In fact, free agency is their justification for the designer gospel they have refurbished to suit their individual tastes. We all know members like this. What they don't seem to grasp in all their enlightened brilliance is that they are playing right into Satan's hands. Satan wants them to feel proud and superior, to scoff at the seemingly picky rules we have.

They've forgotten that Christ runs this church, not mortals. God's laws are unchangeable and eternal, not someone's notions that sway in the breeze and adapt to each new social trend. Former Young Women General President Ardeth G. Kapp once quoted Elaine Cannon: 'When the prophet speaks, the debate is over'. This is because the prophet is speaking for God and telling us what he would have us hear—he is not just the president of a corporation giving us his personal views.

When we pray for a testimony and get the answer that this church is exactly what it claims to be, the restored gospel of Jesus Christ, then we need to embrace every part of it. This is not a smorgasbord of ideas from which we choose. It is the grand feast God has prepared of which we are privileged to partake.

Faith, obedience, commitment—these take effort, sometimes against gale-force storms. Those unwilling to sacrifice and work will fall by the wayside, then claim it's where the wiser folks actually belong. But being outside the mainstream is not a badge of honor; it's actually an admittance of weakness. Living in the gray area at the fringe takes little, if any, effort. Like laziness, it spawns rationalization, something the obedient never have to worry about. The dedicated members don't have to excuse or explain themselves—they simply continue working, inching along the path Christ outlined. Only when we stray do we feel we have to justify our choices. Perhaps that's one way to tell if you're at risk: only the liberal Mormons feel the need to explain their twist on faith".

Sam Harris on Religious Moderation (2005)

Tom: Before we get into the panel discussion, I want to play two clips from Sam Harris from his 2005 lecture, The View from the End of the World. He takes aim at religious moderates—essentially religious liberals.

Sam Harris (Audio Clip):
"Another problem with religious moderation is that it represents a fundamentally unprincipled use of reason. It really is intellectually bankrupt. At least fundamentalists talk about evidence. You ask a fundamentalist why he believes Jesus is coming back, and he'll give you an evidentiary story or an argument: 'The New Testament confirms Old Testament prophecy,' or 'All the prophecies in the Bible have come true in history'. These are not good, reasonable claims, but if they were true, this would be an argument that the Bible is emanating from an omniscient source.

What do moderates talk about when you ask why they believe in God? Moderates talk about meaning—that this belief gives their lives meaning. They talk about the good consequences of believing as they do.

Appreciate for a moment what a non sequitur this is when transferred to any other subject. Imagine your neighbor claimed to believe there is a diamond buried in his backyard the size of a refrigerator. You see him out digging every Sunday with his family. Imagine how you would feel about his mental faculties if he said, 'Well, this belief gives my life a tremendous amount of meaning; my family and I really enjoy digging for this on Sundays, and it has a remarkable bonding effect on us,' or, 'I wouldn't want to live in a universe where there wasn't a diamond buried in my backyard'. These responses are deeply inadequate—they are the responses of a madman or an idiot. Yet change the subject to the existence of God who hears your prayers and protects your family despite daily devastation in the world, and all bets are off.

Another problem with religious moderation is that it's not only intellectually bankrupt, it is theologically bankrupt. I've read the books: God is not a moderate. Living strictly by it gets you medieval Europe, burning people alive for heresy. If your neighbor can say something to your child so spiritually wayward that it puts your child in peril of eternal torment, that person next door is far more dangerous than a child molester. Really believing this stuff has consequences, and we secularists and moderates have lost touch with the fact that millions of people really believe this stuff".

Panel Debate: The Future of Mormonism

Tom: In our email group, I ranted about the reaction of liberal Mormons to that Meridian article. John Dehlin and others made a big deal out of it, using public muscle to get Meridian to pull it and republish it revised with the claws removed. When I read it, I actually liked that she called a spade a spade. Five years ago, I would have applauded every word. Then I thought: that means there's no place at the table for me. I had my wife read it, and she disagreed with everything, while I agreed! She felt it isolated members, but Joanie has doctrine, Bruce R. McConkie, and strict fundamentalism on her side.

Randy: Mike Tannehill still holds a calling in the church, so there's plenty of room for fundamentalists. What you're envisioning is sloughing off the liberal wing and retrenching the fundamentalist core.

Tom: The church as an institution—LDS Inc. with Thomas S. Monson as CEO—tries to appear nuanced, but then waves of retrenchment hit from Boyd K. Packer or Dallin H. Oaks. Growing up orthodox, I looked at people who only came twice a month or skipped Sunday School as hypocrites. I was fasting, paying offerings, praying day and night, and taking this seriously. Joanie feels insulted that cafeteria Mormons want all the benefits of the community while skirting the rules. Two years ago, Elder Russell M. Nelson gave an entire General Conference address excoriating cafeteria Mormonism. The hierarchy dictates what Mormonism is; it doesn't allow cafeteria picking and choosing.

Jesse: But there has always been a strain within Mormonism that takes a broad-tent, liberal approach—people like Hugh B. Brown or Sterling McMurrin. Since correlation, it's been cracked down on, but that is their Mormonism. There are people who are active believers, hold callings like bishop or Relief Society president, vote Democrat, and have a broad, inclusive worldview. Why should an article disparage people who actively identify with the community?

Bob Caswell: I look at this from a different angle: do you want the band-aid ripped off fast, or peeled back slowly while pretending you don't feel pain? Coming at it from how the church harms people: if the church retrenches and becomes ultra-orthodox, people realize how crazy it is much faster! That liberal state is just an unhealthy, transitory phase. It keeps you one foot in each camp. Let it shrink, let it collapse under its stalwart crazies, and push people out so they can start their real lives post-Mormonism.

Glenn: Wait, what are we arguing here? Is the title of this episode The Future of Mormonism?

Bob: Yes! In 20 years, does Mormonism water down—accepting gays, ordaining women, treating commandments loosely—or does it shrink into a fundamentalist core? I'd rather see it collapse on its stalwart crazies than live on forever in a watered-down state requiring endless mental gymnastics.

Tom: Liberal Mormons are just as judgmental of conservatives as conservatives are of them. They pretend they aren't, but in the back of their minds they think the orthodox member is a crazy fanatic.

Bob: Exactly. When I was a liberal Mormon, I took pride in watching R-rated movies, drinking green tea, and shopping on Sunday. I felt superior to the conservatives, thinking, "I figured out we can be normal people and still get into the celestial kingdom". But looking back, that middle ground was silly. Drawing a line between green tea and black tea is even sillier than avoiding tea entirely! If the church had dialed back the gray area, my transition out would have taken five months instead of five years.

Glenn: But isn't there another option? Looking back 20 years, General Conference is saying almost the exact same things today. Why assume it will drastically become either tiny fundamentalists or totally liberal?

Jesse: If you have 10 liberal members in a ward, that ward becomes more inclusive and safer for marginalized people. If everyone with doubts just leaves, the institution becomes harsher and more fundamentalist.

Bob: Here is the math: do you want to make everyone's life inside the church 5% less terrible, or do you want 10 people to have a 100% better life by leaving completely? I'd rather save whole-bodied people quickly than slow down the boiling rate of frogs dying in the pot.

Randy: Bob's frog-in-the-pot metaphor encapsulates it perfectly. I left within seven months of my faith crisis. If I had lingered as a slow-burning liberal Mormon for years, my young kids would have been indoctrinated, creating painful family conflict later. The math favors getting as many people out of the boiling pot as possible.

The Vote: What Do the Panelists Want?

Bob: Let's go around the quorum and state what we actually want the church to become:
- Bob: I want it reined in and more conservative like the '90s, forcing people to confront the reality and exit quickly.
- Jesse: I want more space for liberal Mormons, because having room to question gradually is how most people safely navigate their way out.
- Glenn: If forced to choose, I want the church to interpret scriptures like Job or Nephi figuratively rather than literally, focus on the Beatitudes, and actually do good in the community.
- Tom: I want it to be more conservative. As someone who sacrificed for decades trying to live every strict rule, having cafeteria Mormons skip callings, skip home teaching, and act superior invalidates the real sacrifices the orthodox 20% make to keep the church running.
- Randy: Conservative. Contraction saves more people across generations than waiting for incremental internal reform.

Bob: Three to two for fundamentalist contraction—we win!

Randy: Anyone for the closing prayer?

(Music plays: "Lord, my path has gone astray, I'm just trying to find my way...")

Retroactive Announcement

Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund. Just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.

I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and accepting new clients. So if you or someone you know is seeking coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes. Thanks again for listening.

Ep 34 – Damned Liberals
Broadcast by