Ep 20 – Belief-umentary: Religulous vs. Kumare

The full quorum (Bob, Glenn, Jesse, Matt, Randy, & Tom) gets together to review, discuss, and compare two movies that both try to tackle the topic of organized religion: Religulous and Kumare. They are both available via Netflix streaming, but you don’t need to see either movie to follow the discussion.

Episode 20: Belief-umentary (Religulous vs. Kumare)

Intro / Voiceover:
Ladies and gentlemen, in our right corner: the comedian of crunch, the perennial punch-liner, the Real Time deal, Bill Maher!
(Bill Maher clip: "I certainly honestly believe religion is detrimental to the progress of humanity".)
And in our left corner: the swami of slaughter, the guru of gore, Kumaré himself, Vikram Gandhi!
(Vikram Gandhi clip: "I am not who you think that I am".)
Let's get ready to... rumble!

Glenn: All right, all right, that was a little stupid. I don't know what made me get all Michael Buffer on you. I promise I'll never do anything that stupid again. Tonight, we're simply going to compare Kumaré and Religulous—two documentaries on belief. So, you might call them belief-umentaries. I did it again. Okay, I'm just going to shut up now.

Theme / Intro: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the core.

Glenn: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund, and once again, I'm joined by our full quorum:
Jesse Smith. (Clip: "We wanted to start with Religulous".)
Bob Caswell. (Clip: "Just your pronunciation didn't improve, that's all".)
Tom Perry. (Clip: "Now, I've got to take this severe left turn".)
Matt Long. (Clip: "When you think about it for a little longer, it's still bullshit, but I got to tell you...")
And Randy Snyder. (Clip: "He went out and picked all the low-hanging fruit".)

Just one piece of news for you all: we have a new survey. It's short and informative and delicious to the taste; we desire all to receive it. Seriously, the last time we had 61 responses, which is pretty good, but we think we have around 3,000 regular listeners. So, head over to [suspicious link removed] and look for the survey link on the top right of the page. We'd love to get your feedback. We think it'll help our podcast get better, and as soon as we have some significant findings, we'll definitely return and report.

All right, now that we've got that out of the way, we have a special treat here from one of my favorite people in the whole world, Brother Jake. Now, you may remember Brother Jake from such YouTube videos as, you know, all the YouTube videos that Brother Jake does. So, Brother Jake took a few moments to sit down and do a quick synopsis of the documentaries Religulous and Kumaré. And here it is right now.

Brother Jake's Synopsis

Brother Jake: Hi, I'm Brother Jake. So, Religulous is this really neat documentary about this supersmart dude named Bill Maher who goes around and talks to people about religion. And the best part about it is that he starts off the movie by saying that he just wants to find out why people have religious beliefs. And sure, it might seem a little strange that he went about this project to connect with and understand people by getting them on camera, asking them questions specifically tailored to embarrass them, and then laughing in their face when they try to answer. But I think he proved a point: religion is terrible because all religions have terrible things about them. And granted, he didn't do a great job from an academic or scientific perspective of showing why religion specifically is so awful, since all the bad things he pointed out about religions—like oppression, manipulation, and exploitation of believers—could and do exist in pretty much any large organization based around an ideology, like say a political party. And yeah, there may be some irony in the fact that somebody who so often used science and academia as a counterpoint to religious doctrine used such a non-scientific, non-academic approach to prove those very counterpoints. But here's what Bill Maher is trying to say: religions are bad because they're using an enticing premise to draw people in and manipulate or exploit those people for personal gain. And we all know that that's something that Bill Maher would never do.

Now, Kumaré is this other documentary about this Indian guy named Vikram who grew up in New Jersey and was so fed up with people acting like gurus and exploiting people that he decided to act like a guru and exploit people himself to see if they would follow him. Because we all know the best way to fight the rampant exploitation of people's gullibility is to tap into that gullibility under a false identity and then film their acceptance of your façade so that you can make a documentary about how gullible they are! Anyway, so these people totally buy it. All he had to do was completely change his appearance, voice, mentality, and lifestyle for like a year, which proves his point that gurus are totally not legit. Anyone can be a guru as long as you say and do exactly what a guru would say and do all the time—kind of like how by learning all about statistics and doing everything a statistician would do until I get a job as a statistician, I can prove that statistics is all made up!

Part 1: Reviewing Bill Maher's Religulous

Glenn: Isn't Brother Jake just awesome? All right, now that we've got that out of the way, let's get on to our panel discussion on that first movie, Religulous. First of all, I don't know how to pronounce it. Everybody says it a different way, and it's just an annoying word. Religulous, right? Supposed to be like "ridiculous".

Panelist: It's pronounced Religulous because it's a conflation of religion and ridiculous.

Panelist: We get that, but it's just an annoying word.

Jesse: So, we wanted to start with Religulous.

Bob: Your pronunciation didn't improve, that's all.

Jesse: Religulous was clearly an indictment on religion, and it took a nice sweep at all of them: Islam, Judaism, Mormonism, Scientology, Catholicism, and general Christianity. Bill Maher spliced in funny clips to highlight points. It was edited pretty well, and Bill was as likable as he can possibly be in this film—much more than on his TV show or stand-up. It was a lot better than I expected given my disdain for Bill Maher's arrogance and heavy-handed approach.

Bob: Really? Because I had the opposite reaction. The movie was too ambitious. When the scope is the religions of the entire world, don't do a personal narrative where you show pictures from childhood, interview your mom and sister, and film yourself in the passenger seat of a car! Bill Maher couldn't separate himself from the subject matter. And leading up to the end, he has this super-long soapbox speech: "The plain fact is religion must die for mankind to live... The hour is getting very late... Grow up or die". It was all about Bill Maher when it should have been about religion.

Randy: He's a stand-up comedian by trade. Stand-up comedians always start from themselves and look outward. He's not a journalistic documentary maker. It's a comedy and propaganda piece.

Matt: It's just as much a documentary as anything Michael Moore puts out.

Bob: When he gets to Mormonism, Bill stands outside the Salt Lake Temple and says, "To be a Mormon is to believe some really crazy stuff—crazy even by the standards of the big religions". Then he lists: God lives on a planet near the star Kolob; Jesus was conceived by God having sex with Mary; dark skin is a curse; caffeine is evil; magic underwear; and secret passwords to get into heaven. And they show a clip of a guy sucking a woman's breast as the visual representation of Mormonism! That's totally out of context.

Glenn: Tal Bachmann was on, and I thought what he had to say was representative of many who leave: "The moment you acknowledge to yourself that Joseph Smith did not tell the truth... you just committed social suicide". But the most disingenuous part of the movie is that Bill claims he preaches "the gospel of I don't know"—selling doubt instead of certainty. Yet he is completely certain about his conclusions and preaches with arrogant certitude that religion must die!

Randy: He went out and picked all the low-hanging fruit—fundamentalist truck drivers, storefront preachers, and people who believe in creationism. When critics say he picked low-hanging fruit, I have to ask: is the fundamentalist low-hanging fruit actually the majority of believers? He goes after dogmatic fundamentalism, which is the real problem.

Glenn: But he frames it as an investigation to find out why rational people believe, and then he completely ignores serious inquiry. He spent so much time with that Hasidic Jew who sells gadgets to circumvent Shabbat laws, and barely any time with the psychologist of religion!

Matt: My favorite part was in the Vatican when he asks the Catholic priest if the Pope should live in such extravagance, and the priest bluntly says, "Well, of course not"! No Mormon leader would ever say that about their prophet.

Randy: And interviewing the U.S. Senator who doubts evolution and says, "You don't have to pass an IQ test to be in the Senate"!

Glenn: And interviewing the theme-park Jesus at Holy Land Experience! The actor used the classic analogy: the Trinity is like water—it can be steam, ice, or liquid. Bill was stopped in his tracks because he'd never heard it before! But instead of showing his genuine reaction, he cut away to explain from the car why it's still bullshit.

Matt: When it came out in 2008, it was groundbreaking because there wasn't much mainstream secular/atheist media. But Julia Sweeney's one-woman show, Letting Go of God, did it so much better—heartfelt, poignant, and without pretending to be an objective documentary.

Part 2: Reviewing Vikram Gandhi's Kumaré

Glenn: Now onto Kumaré. Vikram Gandhi, an Indian-American from New Jersey, set out to see if spiritual leaders were for real or just full of it. He grew out his hair and beard, put on an accent imitating his grandmother, and created the persona of Kumaré.

Jesse: At first, it started like a Borat-style prank—he even drew a symbol on a follower's forehead that looked like a penis, and did absurd yoga moves. But once he began dealing with people on an individual level, he couldn't go through with mocking them.

Tom: He got emotionally involved. These were vulnerable people dealing with real struggles, genuinely opening up to him. He would have had to be a world-class asshole to keep exploiting them as a gag.

Matt: When he realized he had to unveil himself, you could see the panic. It shows how someone who starts a religion as a conscious fraud—like Joseph Smith—can get caught up once people heap adoration, love, and validation onto them. How do you ever step away?

Bob: When Stephen Colbert asked Vikram on The Colbert Report if he got crazy tail as Kumaré, he cleverly answered that the rules for a fake spiritual leader are stricter than those for a real spiritual leader!

Glenn: Vikram's exit strategy was his "mirror philosophy"—teaching his followers that they never needed a guru, that Kumaré was just an illusion, and that the power was within themselves all along. But he was trying to have it both ways: claiming gurus are unnecessary while ignoring that these people made genuine personal breakthroughs because they had him to lean on!

Randy: The secular takeaway is that there is no metaphysical power. Everything gained in religion comes from human connection and the psychology within ourselves—there is no external divine magic.

Bob: Comparing the two films: Bill Maher's Religulous is an indictment that all religion must die, while Kumaré shows that even when the premise is completely fake, human community and faith can have tangible secular value. And at the end, Vikram Gandhi actually underwent a character arc and changed, whereas Bill Maher remained just as smug, arrogant, and unchanged from scene one to the end.

Matt: If you're tackling religion on film, either be a full, objective documentary or tell an honest personal narrative like Julia Sweeney. Don't try to straddle the middle by pretending to be an open investigation when you're just pushing an ego-driven agenda.

Glenn: Well, that wraps up our review of the two "belief-umentaries"! Check out [suspicious link removed], take our survey, and leave a comment. Anyone for the closing mantra?

Glenn (retroactive message): Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund. Just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast. I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload and accepting new clients. If you or someone you know is seeking coaching or therapy services, please reach out for a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes. Thanks again for listening.

Ep 20 – Belief-umentary: Religulous vs. Kumare
Broadcast by