Ep 104 – The Placebo Effect – Part 1

Chelsea Shields Strayer joins Glenn, Matt, and Scott for a discusion on The Placebo Effect. Part 1 covers Chelsea’s time as a cultural anthropologist in Ghana, why she got involved in Africa, and how her field work among the Ashanti changed the way she views her Mormon culture. We also discuss cultural relativism — when is it OK to judge a culture’s vices and become an advocate for change? And we begin to discuss the Placebo Effect based on the faith healers Chelsea studied in Africa — how an inert medication or treatment can actually cause measurable physical change in a person’s body.

Episode 104: The Placebo Effect, Part 1
Teaser: The Biology of Expectation

Chelsea Shields Strayer: First, I just want to define placebo. Most people think when I say placebo, it's all in someone's head. You know, it's not a real thing. But the real reality is I'm having a biochemical, physiological change occurring. But the difference is there wasn't active medication given to me; it was an inert medication.

But I would change the word from "belief" to "expectation," because it's the expectation of what will follow, whether it's positive or negative, that changes that physical state. Humans are not the strongest. We're not the bravest. We don't have the sharpest teeth. The thing that we're really good at is what we call plasticity.

Plasticity. Plasticity.

Our brains and bodies are enormously adaptable. There's very little evolutionary bias that you would succeed at a higher rate if you were a better believer. But what we see is there's no question that people that belonged survived and reproduced at higher rates than people that were ostracized from the group. Most religions are based on a lot of what we call costly signals, or like signs that you're part of the group: "I wear garments, therefore you can trust me." 100% of human survival is based in our ability to be taken care of by someone else. That process can be manipulated.

The key here is understanding that there's a physiological change happening due to expectation. It's a social or psychological trigger that then causes this chemical response. The expectation changes that physical state. That process can be manipulated.

Theme Voiceover: This is Infants on Thrones. The philosophies of men mingled with humor. We are the quorum.
Introduction: Chelsea Shields Strayer

Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund, and guess what? I'm really excited about today's episode.

Does it sound better now?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Yes, yes.

Glenn Ostlund: Okay, cool.

This is Chelsea Shields Strayer. Now, she's a well-known Mormon feminist who founded WAVE, which is Women Advocating for Voice and Equality. She's also on the executive board of Ordain Women. She's a TED Fellow and is nearly finished with a double PhD in both cultural anthropology and biological anthropology from Boston University. And she spent a lot of time in Ghana studying the Ashanti. This isn't the first Mormon-themed podcast she's been on, but it is apparently the best.

So, be honest: some of the better questions you've gotten from this group than other podcasts?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Oh, heck yeah!

Glenn Ostlund: So, this is another one of our discussions that went nearly three hours and could have gone much longer. We seem to be doing that a lot lately. So, we'll break this up into two parts.

In part one, we get to know Chelsea a little bit. We learn about her background, the reasons she chose cultural anthropology as a field of study. We spend some time talking about culture, both what she saw in Africa and how that changed the way she started seeing things back home. We talk about witchcraft and placebos and cultural relativism. And we end part one with a minor debate between Chelsea and fellow Infants Matt and Scott, who challenge the idea that alternative medicines could possibly be more beneficial in some cases than biomedicine.

Now, in part two, we start off with the definition of placebo. That it isn't that the placebo is just a sugar pill, it's nothing, and that the benefit that a person gets from it is in their own head, a figment of their imagination. No, it's not that. Instead, a placebo actually creates real, measurable biochemical responses in people. But that change is not the result of an active ingredient in the medicine or treatment; it's the result of that person's social and cultural expectations. I like to think of it as Dumbo's black feather.

(Audio clip – Dumbo / "When I See an Elephant Fly")
Jim Crow: "I be done seen about everything when I see an elephant fly."
Crow: "What'd you say, boy?"
Jim Crow: "I said when I see an elephant fly."

Glenn Ostlund: Dumbo didn't just think he was flying; he was actually flying—you know, as cartoon elephants with really big ears tend to do. But the feather wasn't behind what he did; it was Dumbo's belief in the feather. So, you know, I mean, if you can compare it to Dumbo, it's got to be true.

Now, part two also explores the evolution of the human body. Why did we evolve so that our internal punishment and reward systems would shoot chemicals out of our brains in response to achieving or violating cultural expectations? We also explore the idea that just as there are placebos which have a positive effect, there are also nocebos that can have a negative effect. And then, of course, you have the term that I'm coining for you all today: the mobebos, which are the positive or negative effects of achieving or violating the cultural expectations of Mormonism.

So buckle up, 'cause this is going to be fascinating—and for some possibly frustrating, and for others possibly life-changing. And apparently, we asked some really good, great, brilliant questions. I mean, really:

(Montage clip)
Voices: "It's a good question... That's a really good question... It's a great question... That's a great point... That's a great comparison... That's a brilliant question... That's a great question..."

Glenn Ostlund: Yeah, I know. Sorry, Chelsea, I couldn't help it. And just in case any of you listened to our "Shakespeare in the Bush" minisode and went away from that scratching your head a bit, I'll add some explanation at the end of part one here to connect what you heard there to what you're going to hear here.
Meet Chelsea: Conferences, Hemophilia, and Pain Management

Glenn Ostlund: So, Chelsea, you're pretty much a podcast pro. You've done this multiple times.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Anytime.

Glenn Ostlund: Yeah. And so I listened to the Mormon history guy—I listened to that one, and then that link that you sent to me, that was like a BYU radio interview?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Right, the radio interview.

Glenn Ostlund: Radio interview, yeah. But I haven't heard any of the Mormon Matters, or you did a Mormon Stories one, too?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Uh-huh.

Glenn Ostlund: Was it just you, or were you like a panel?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: No, it was part of a conference. It was like a live recording of a conference in D.C.

Glenn Ostlund: Okay, right. All right. So, the way we do it, we do a lot of post-editing stuff, so we just start it rolling and have a conversation and then add stuff later on. So, we're going now, and if there's something that you say and you want to back up and go, "I want to say that again," it's totally easy to do. So, you've met Scott.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: I have. We hung out this weekend, actually.

Scott: Yes, we did.

Glenn Ostlund: And what were you doing in Phoenix?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: So, I was actually speaking—it's kind of a strange connection, but I was speaking at a national hemophilia conference on pain management. So, how to manage pain with social and cultural behavioral adjustments rather than just pain medication. People tend to get addicted to pain medicine, there's lots of side effects, and I kind of go over a lot of ways we can mediate pain with just the way we approach it.

Glenn Ostlund: And that was something, Matt, you said you were interested from the TED blog, right?

Matt: Yeah, and it was less the physical pain management, but the discussion about the social pains—anxiety, heartbreak, and those types of things—and how can those same strategies be applied to the emotional trauma.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Right, right. That's a great question, by the way. Yeah, so I was there for that. We can definitely get into that if you want; I don't know if we want to start out with that. But so I was there to kind of present that on a Saturday, and then on Friday we just kind of said, "Let's get some Mormon feminists together and we'll have..." You know, I thought it was going to be like in someone's living room and we're going to like sit around and talk. Ask Scott—it ended up being like a rented-out room in the city with like 65 people and like Q&A. It was like pretty intense, actually.

Scott: Yeah, it was a pretty big crowd for a Friday night.

Glenn Ostlund: Yeah, well, you've got a pretty strong group—would you classify it as ex-Mo? It's kind of like Mormon Stories group or whatever that group is in Phoenix, right? There's a huge group down there.

Scott: Oh, you're talking to me? Yeah, we've got a really big—I don't know, we call the Phoenix Open Mormons group, that's about 500 people now in our Facebook group. But yeah, I mean, we can get some big crowds if you have a draw. I mean, you could easily have 300 people if there was an event that was worthwhile.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Well, thanks a lot, buddy!

Scott: I meant like a party, like a big party!

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Yeah, that did come off really badly.

Scott: That's why I don't throw my house parties anymore; they got too big.

Glenn Ostlund: Yeah, thrown under the bus! Son of a—
The Rapid-Fire Get-to-Know-You Quiz

Glenn Ostlund: All right. So, I put together a little informal get-to-know-you quiz that I'm going to put you on the spot and just ask you a series of questions, and you just give me the answer that comes to your mind. One you probably get all the time: paper or plastic?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Paper, always.

Glenn Ostlund: All right. Beach or mountains?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Mountains, always.

Glenn Ostlund: Okay. Relief Society or Elders Quorum?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Elders Quorum. I would be grateful to be in there for an actual debate. And the only reason I say that—'cause I like Relief Society, but I'm intellectual and I'm into an even disagreement of opinion without hard feelings. What I've realized in Relief Society is that—and this makes sense if you study the culture of gender in America—to have a disagreement means one of us is wrong, and someone leaves the conversation feeling like either they're wrong or that I think they're wrong. And so it's harder to respectfully disagree in Relief Society, and that's very hard for me as someone who really thrives in kind of the headspace of debate. And so Relief Society has always been a hard thing, even though I've been a teacher for most of that time; it's been hard for me.

Glenn Ostlund: Cool. That's a way bigger answer than I expected, but that's fantastic!

Scott: And I think you're setting a standard for some of the rest of these questions. No, I was just going to say, I have to say from the other night when Chelsea was here, during the Q&A session, she asked people to form a line, and I kind of jumped up and went first in line to ask a question 'cause I was really excited about the things we were talking about. And she called me out for being an aggressive man that jumped to the front; she said that was indicative of our gender roles or something. Although in our group, we do have some aggressive women.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: No, I was just teasing the group that the line that formed was all men, basically. And this idea of public forums of discussion tend to be particularly men, right? So, my husband and I are both professors, and we'll have the same lesson, right? I'll go to Relief Society, he'll go to Priesthood, and we talk about the lesson after, and it's drastically different discussions. And not only that, we can say the exact same thing and we get drastically different interpretations. I'm kind of looked down upon for wanting to debate heavily or not agree with everything, and he's kind of looked upon as, "Oh, he's the professor in the room," right? So, it's just an interesting conundrum in our culture.

Glenn Ostlund: All right. Star Trek or Star Wars?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Ooh, neither. I'm not a fan. I'll take science non-fiction all the time, but science fiction is harder for me.

Glenn Ostlund: Would you rather have a personal psychic reading or sit in on a hypnotist show?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Hypnotist. I think it's fascinating.

Glenn Ostlund: Neil Diamond or not Neil Diamond?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Neil Diamond every day.

Glenn Ostlund: Oh my gosh. There are two types of people in this world: those who like Neil Diamond and those who don't. My ex-wife loves him. Okay. Dualism or materialism?

Scott: Now we're talking.

Glenn Ostlund: Yeah, that was for you, Scott.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Materialism. Only because I think dualism is a Western academic bias that's not accurate to the lived experience. If I was answering that question without the binary, I would say pluralism. That's a more realistic portrayal or theory of the world in which people interact and live—is pluralistic rather than dualistic. And so a lot of the Western philosophy that came out of dualism, that came out of Descartes, I think is flawed because of its binary.

Glenn Ostlund: So how would you describe pluralism, then?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Pluralism—and this is Kwame Anthony Appiah, Cosmopolitanism, that's the book that was recently out, the philosopher from Africa. Basically, where I do my research in West Africa, we see a ton of pluralism. They believe in multiple different theories at the same time coexisting in one. For example, the people I work with can believe in Allah, they can believe in their traditional gods and priests in their pantheons, they can believe in Joseph Smith, they can believe in Jesus Christ. To them, why does believing in one negate the belief in another? You can have all of them at the same time. And so part of the mind-body dualism binary, even the Lévi-Straussian dismissal of that philosophy, is it's very Western and it puts everything into binaries, which is not the actual experience of most people throughout the world.

Glenn Ostlund: So are we talking about the same thing—that there's more to existence than just your brain and that there's some spirit that's outside of yourself?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Right. So, for example, I talk about this a lot with people. I had a big debate at Sunstone with a UVU philosophy professor. We were talking about what is truth, and he kept going back to the intellectual, cognitive, deductive reasoning of truth. And I kept saying, "Look, something could be cognitively illogical but still be socially true, or psychosocially true, or emotionally true". Something can be physically efficacious but not be cognitively accurate. So, I can receive a priesthood blessing as an atheist, and it can still be efficacious without it being true.

Now, if we're getting down—this is why I said materialist earlier—to kind of the Steven Pinker "ghost in the machine," do we have a soul or is it all just neural networks, I shocked my entire graduate class by agreeing and saying I actually think it's all neural networks. I don't think we have an immaterial spirit or soul in the way that we've come to kind of conceive of this. And this is when I was very believing: I believe that our God, our Mormon God, works through natural genius. He's a biochemist, he's a physiologist, he understands the way that neural synaptic connections work. And I think that that, to me, is the miracle of evolution and the miracle of science—is the complexity. So, I'm a total materialist when it comes to that.

Glenn Ostlund: So in graduate school, they were shocked because you were at BYU, is that right?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: They assumed that anyone religious would have believed in this kind of ghost in the machine, soul directing everything. And I don't think they understood that deep at the heart of Mormonism is actually this understanding of the natural world, and that we believe miracles or even the spirit works through natural means. And I think that that's kind of a fascinating concept of our past that gets lost sometimes.

Glenn Ostlund: Cool. All right, final question that I prepared: Richard Dawkins or Joseph Smith?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: That's a tough one! Well, Dawkins on evolutionary biology, Joseph Smith on theology. Anything outside of evolutionary biology that Richard Dawkins talks about—for example, culture or the meme—most of us in anthropology think is pretty bad, to say that politely. We just don't think he has much leg to stand on. But when he talks about biology, he's very good, so in small quantities. Joseph Smith, the reason why I choose him with theology is I think that there's a hopefulness in his theology that I think I will always admire, respect, and desire, quite frankly.

Glenn Ostlund: Yeah, it's funny you say that, because there's a meme that's going around the internet that says: "Should I listen to Richard Dawkins? Is he talking about evolutionary biology? Yes. Is he saying anything else? No."

Chelsea Shields Strayer: I feel the same way about Jared Diamond. When they're really in their own field, they do a great job; but when these scientists start talking about human society—even E.O. Wilson—they really fall short. They miss a lot of the theory, they miss a lot of the background, they miss a lot of the stuff we've been doing for years.
Finding Anthropology and Heading to Ghana

Glenn Ostlund: So, your background is first as a cultural anthropologist and then as a biological anthropologist. For people listening that don't know what that is, could you give a really quick explanation of what you study and why you got interested in it?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Absolutely. Cultural anthropology is basically the study of man—how we evolved everything from our body to our society to the things we create. It encompasses how we behave, how we interact, our political systems, religious systems, familial systems, kinship systems. I always tell people it's the greatest thing to study in the world, 'cause any interest you have, from dance to cooking to warfare, you can study in anthropology.

I got interested in anthropology originally as a BYU-Idaho student. I was actually going to run track for Ricks when it was Ricks. So, I went up to Ricks on a scholarship to run track, and then they got rid of track that year. And I was at BYU-Idaho having to figure out what I'm going to do if I'm not an athlete. And I realized: hey, I really like cultures and languages and people. When I got back to BYU after a couple of study abroad programs, they had anthropology, and I found my one true love.

Glenn Ostlund: Now, Chelsea, did they get rid of the track program at Ricks because they figured out that you have to wear shorts?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: It's a great question, 'cause the rules are absurd!

Scott: My sister and her new convert husband went to Ricks right after they got married. She saw President Clark, walked up to him and said, "Hi, I'm a student here. This is my new convert husband. We're so excited to be here." And he looked down at her shoes—they happened to be flip-flops—and he said, "Well, I hope next time you're more appropriately dressed."

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Wow. So, at BYU-Idaho, I was super interested in Africa. I took African studies classes. It was a stupid young—I think we've all met these girls, right? And I was one of them: "I just want to go to Africa and save the world," like a Mother Teresa syndrome. I was 19 years old, and I was getting a lot of pressure to marry my boyfriend, who was an RM, from my institute director, my bishop, my home bishop, my grandparents. People would ask things like, "Well, do you hate marriage?" I was like, "I'm 19!"

So Africa became kind of this fake lifeline. I would say things like, "Well, you know what? I'll make that decision once I follow this dream." People would respond, "Well, you can go on a mission with your husband someday." And for some reason, as a young, good Mormon girl, I couldn't just say, "That's not what I want; I'm making a different choice." But I could put my stake in the ground and say, "I have to do this thing first."

I met a biochemistry professor from the University of Ghana at BYU. We became friends, he said, "Come on over." I sent him an email: "I'm coming to Ghana." I got on a plane by myself at 20, leaving the country for the first time. It was back in 2000, when I didn't even know if the internet worked, didn't know if someone was going to be there to pick me up. It plopped this white Mormon raised in a traditional family—eight kids, CES dad—in the heart of Africa by myself, and forced me to figure out life. I ate soap one day 'cause I didn't know if it was bread or food!

The first time was six months. Those first couple months, you guys, I was a pissy, lots of makeup, hair done, wearing heels every day Mormon BYU girl plopped in Africa. My makeup would melt off; I'd try to blow dry my hair, there was no electricity; the toilet was literally a hole in the ground. The first night I fell asleep, I was scared to death—a gecko landed on my chest and crawled down my body, 'cause he fell asleep on the ceiling and fell on me. I had no idea what it was, so I spent the whole night awake huddled in the corner.

What it did over the course of six months was allow me to figure out who I was outside of the cultural script that I was given and had always followed. A lot of colleges explain culture to undergraduates as: fish don't understand that they're in water 'cause that's all they've ever known; they can't see it. Same with us: we cannot recognize what aspects of our life, what decisions, what type of behavior we're experiencing and perpetuating as culture until we're forced to step into a totally new place, and then we can come back and understand that.
The Gospel vs. Culture Box

Glenn Ostlund: That raises an interesting question: the separation between church and culture, or the gospel and culture. In the early days when I was starting to question the church, that was like this ready-made division: if I want to believe it and cherish it, I'm putting it in the "gospel" box; if it's something that makes me crazy, I'm going to put that in the "culture" box. And it took a long time for that culture box to widen until it basically subsumed the gospel.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Anyone I've met who has truly understood another person from a different culture and understood their passions and lifestyle, it's very hard for you to delegitimize their life experiences. It forces you to have an open mind. As Mormons, we tend to be isolated in our bubble; we think the world is one way until we really experience it a different way.

The reverse culture shock was tough. I remember my father picking me up from the airport and us driving home, and him talking about the girl in the ward that just made cheerleader camp. And I remember saying to him—he was a seminary teacher, we had no money—"There's more money in your pocket than some of these people I lived with have for a year. Why are we talking about someone going to cheerleader camp?" Or a friend would be upset 'cause she didn't get the car that she wanted, and I was like, "Seriously? People are dying. Why do you care about that?"

In my academic life, I study the evolution and elicitation of placebo effects—in other words, how we are able to elicit a physiological response from another human being with nothing more than a psychological or social trigger. And in my Mormon life, it had always been quite separate. At the beginning, I was embarrassed; I felt like my colleagues or professors wouldn't think I'm as rigorous of a student if they thought I was committed to a particular worldview.
Sacrificing Chickens and Answered Prayers

Chelsea Shields Strayer: What changed that was beginning to break apart the Ashanti religion that I was studying. I would go to a traditional healing ceremony—they're three or four hours long—and watch the spirit possession and animal sacrifice.

One time, they kill animals dependent on the type of ritual they want to do; one of them was an answer to a question. You can drop an egg, or you can use a kola nut. In this particular case, they used a chicken: if the chicken flops, the answer is yes; if the chicken just dies without any movement, the answer is no.

This guy wanted to start a business and wanted to know if he should invest his money. So they sacrifice a chicken, and it's indeterminate. So they sacrifice another one, and the answer was no. So they decide to sacrifice another chicken, and the answer is yes!

I kind of go and ask the healer and the guy: "Well, if you just keep killing chickens 'til you get the answer you want, isn't that you just determining the answer you want?" And their answer was so clear: "Well, we can never trick the gods. If the answer is no, the chicken will always lie flat."

As I was writing that up that night, something hit me: how many of my prayers have been answered if I logically wrote them out? On one list, all the prayers I've ever offered that have been answered; on another list, the ones that have not been answered. Which column would be longest?

It made me realize: I'm doing the same thing! If I don't get an answer I want, I keep praying—keep killing chickens! And we have so many quotes from Holland and other leaders: "A non-answer is an answer; it's just wait." We have all these ways to rationalize. They may be sacrificing chickens, but our approach to our religion is similar.
Witchcraft, E.E. Evans-Pritchard, and Cultural Realities

Glenn Ostlund: When you say witch, what are you talking about?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Witchcraft is a ubiquitous factor in West Africa: the belief that there are malevolent forces in the world and that you can harness those forces to cause harm to someone else.

Glenn Ostlund: I remember reading Witchcraft, Oracles and Magic Among the Azande by E.E. Evans-Pritchard. He talked about this dark tar substance, black mangu, inside of their gut—that's how you know they are a witch.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Exactly. Evans-Pritchard writes, "The Azande believe..." Dot, dot, dot. He didn't think it was a real thing, but he's qualifying and quantifying what they believe. The postmodern view is that's quite ethnocentric—to assume that it's not fact is negating your informant.

If I'm an American and I say, "Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me," I don't think my words are physically causing anything in the cosmos to transpire. If I'm West African and something bad happens to Glenn after I had malevolent thoughts about him, I actually feel guilty. I feel like my hatred physically changed Glenn's world so that he got hurt. We believe social interactions have an effect in America, too—think about bullying and suicide—yet we don't talk about them as an active force in the way West Africans do.
The 14-Year-Old "Witch" and the Millipede

Glenn Ostlund: Are there ever times when you're comfortable making a normative judgment that a practice is wrong? I would have a hard time sitting through something where they're making a physical claim that we can demonstrably prove is false.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: That's a brilliant question, and that's a question I've grappled with for years. I've sat through ceremonies that I thought were quackery.

I've seen someone pull a millipede out of a woman's body and say, "This is the witchcraft in her." I talked to that same girl—she was a 14-year-old who wrote a letter of confession that she was in fact a witch. She was punished and beaten, and it was a terrible situation. And I saw how once her family had physical proof in the form of this millipede, it was the first time she was allowed back home with her family. For me, I have to say that this witchcraft is real, or else I feel like it's being disingenuous to the lived experience of the people I work with.

Scott: What do you mean by "real"? If you had a continuous CT or X-ray scan of the entire room, and a robot making a determination of whether the millipede came out of her stomach—obviously it didn't!

Chelsea Shields Strayer: But a CT scan is a Western bias!

(Glenn's interjection)
Glenn Ostlund: Let me step in for a minute and try to be a Chelsea whisperer. Scott is saying that if we objectively measure by a CAT scan that a millipede was not actually pulled out of her body, we have evidence of deception and fraud, and therefore this dewitchifying experience is not real. Chelsea, on the other hand, agrees: sure, the millipede was never in her body; there's sleight of hand going on.

However, what is the impact of this sleight of hand? The people seeing the ceremony believe that witchcraft is real and that this girl was a witch, and the extraction of the millipede reinforces that belief. That belief impacts the family in a real, measurable way: they forgive the girl, and they welcome her back into her family, fresh, new, and dewitchified. To them, this is real, and the ceremony has real, measurable results. You can't just stop after the CAT scan and diagnose the situation as "not real." It was real to them because the impact on their lives was real.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: I'm an Einsteinian relativist with behavioral science: the efficacy of how witchcraft works is unconnected to the absolute truth claims that witchcraft exists. My people will be physiologically altered by witchcraft cursings or healings regardless of whether or not I say it exists as an objective thing.

When I talk to people about Mormonism, they say there's this truth claim: God has to exist, Joseph Smith must have seen God and Jesus Christ, he must have had the golden plates. Regardless of whether that's true, that belief still has a real effect on the people who believe in it—to the point of physical alteration, material alteration, changing their lifestyle, determining their decisions. In our Western bias, the only things that are "real" are those we can pick up on a CT scan. We've privileged cognitive logical consistency and materiality so much that we negate anything beyond those means.

I watched that 14-year-old girl be beaten with a rubber whip, and I walked out of the ritual because it was so painful to watch. The healer called me over and got mad at me for walking out. I said, "I can't watch a little girl be beaten." It really tested my boundaries: how relativist am I?

I went home upset, and my neighbor came over and said, "How can you fear a beating when lives are at stake?" It hit me: I think the beating is problematic because I don't believe in the witchcraft. Everyone else believes in the witchcraft, so what's a beating if it gets rid of witchcraft that could kill people?

The girl came back and begged me with tears in her eyes: "Please don't leave, 'cause he won't beat me when you're around." The next time her family showed up—when the millipede came out—she came to me with tears in her eyes again: "Please leave. If you do not leave, he won't beat me, and I'll never be able to return to my family." My understanding of right and wrong would have stopped the ceremony for the day, but she would have never gotten the personhood she needed to be accepted back into her family.
Insider Activism: Ordain Women vs. Female Genital Mutilation

Glenn Ostlund: But isn't pushing for gender equality in the Mormon church the same normative judgment? Why not say that's their culture and leave it alone?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: For me, what it comes down to is: I'm an insider. I'm a cultural Mormon. I was hurt by gender inequality; thousands of my friends have been hurt by gender inequality. I can fight for that because these are my people. Would I go to Sudan and tell people to stop FGM (female genital mutilation)? Not really; that's ethnocentric. Do I want Sudanese women to fight it from the inside? Yes, I do. Change occurs from insiders facilitating that change.

Let me ask you guys a question: how many of you are circumcised?

Glenn Ostlund, Scott, Matt: I am. Yeah. Hey.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: All three of you are circumcised. Part of your foreskin was removed at birth because of a cultural and religious practice. It gave you greater sensitivity, it was taken from you, and yet no one has a problem with this.

In anthropology, female circumcision is a continuum. On the mild end, it's actually less painful, requires less recovery, and has less cost than male circumcision. On the severe end of the spectrum—infibulation, sewing up the vaginal opening, removing the clitoris and labia—it becomes an enormous health catastrophe where women can't give birth or menstruate without extreme danger.

What people don't realize is the cultural weight: women say, "I have to circumcise my daughter, or she's unmarriageable in our society." It's like a Mormon man who doesn't go on a mission. You put a sign on your back that you're less than everyone else. Some guys go on missions just so they don't have the baggage and shame; they give up two years of their life just to have personhood in their culture.

With Ordain Women, we have women whose families have disowned them, parents who told them they couldn't be at their grandmother's deathbed, members who receive hate letters. We're willing to "stop the beating," but what we risk giving up is being accepted into our social circle.
Biological Anthropology & The Placebo Prescription

Glenn Ostlund: So what did biological anthropology add when you went back?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: Cultural anthropology looked at how the ritual integrated her back into her family. But the Ashanti were saying, "No, real witchcraft came out of her; her rash went away because I enacted a biochemical response." Biological anthropology studies the human body and how it evolved over time.

The questions I went back with were:
1. Why did our bodies evolve in such a way that they are manipulable and susceptible to social and psychological triggers?
2. How does a social ritual process affect a physiological state?

In a 2010 survey published in the New York Times, over 50% of U.S.-trained medical doctors surveyed said they regularly prescribe placebos. Doctors give saline injections or sugar pills because they'd rather have a patient go home with something than nothing.

I had an eye doctor friend in Ghana who said, "I could send a patient with advanced glaucoma home and tell her there's nothing I can do, and she'll become depressed, her stress will spike, and her vision will worsen faster. Or I can give her saline drops and tell her, 'Use these every day; it'll help you see a little clearer.' And every time she sees clearer, her expectation works, and her vision remains clearer for longer than the patient who was given no hope."
Debate: Alternative Medicine vs. Biomedicine

Matt: But what about homeopathy, where people spend millions enriching charlatans and foregoing effective cancer treatments? Can't we make a normative judgment that that's wrong?

Chelsea Shields Strayer: In West Africa and in America, people typically try biomedicine first for acute trauma, broken bones, infections, and cancer. People turn to alternative practitioners when biomedicine has failed them—for chronic pain, recurrent cancer, or unexplained illness. And in those realms where things aren't straightforward, manipulating expectations can produce powerful physiological relief.

Matt: I don't accept that premise. People jump to pseudoscientific alternatives all the time. Tim Minchin says, "Do you know what they call alternative medicine that's been proven to work? Medicine." People jump to doTERRA essential oils before ever seeing a doctor.

Chelsea Shields Strayer: If someone in America trusts an essential oil over a doctor, part of that is due to HMOs, insurance costs, and medical malpractice eroding confidence in Western practitioners. Our top killers today aren't infectious diseases; they are heart disease and diabetes caused primarily by diet, stress, and lifestyle. Taking a cholesterol pill is often less effective in the long run than managing stress and diet, but a doctor can't easily force someone to change their lifestyle, so they hand them a pill.

Don't get me wrong: I'm 100% a scientist. I believe in vaccines. Biomedicine has saved millions of lives. If someone is anti-vaccine, I think they are uneducated about the peer-reviewed scientific literature. But taking an oil or a pill is an easy active intervention; altering your behavioral script is hard.
Glenn's Outro: Reflections on "Shakespeare in the Bush"

Glenn Ostlund: That concludes part one; we'll have part two ready for you tomorrow.

Bob teased me over email that the placebo effect has become my new hammer to hit every nail in sight, and he's not far off. As a folklorist, I was trained to view tradition as inherently valuable to the people who keep it alive. The placebo effect gives me a way to talk about that value—not as an imaginary notion, but as a real, measurable physiological response.

When Matt asked Chelsea to explain witchcraft, it brought my mind straight back to Laura Bohannan's essay, "Shakespeare in the Bush." It shows how arrogant it is not to recognize that we all view the world through a traditional cultural lens, and that imposing our worldview on another is the height of cultural imperialism.

My favorite part of that essay is when the Tiv chief says, "People are the same everywhere; therefore, there must be witches everywhere, and we elders can teach you what you cannot see." That was me as a 19-year-old Mormon missionary: believing that everyone needed our ordinances, and that we as "elders" had the authority to give it to them.

And at the end, the chief tells the anthropologist to bring back more stories so they can instruct her in their true meaning. That chief was just as much a cultural elitist as I was in my Mormon bubble. It reminds me of the importance of trying to understand things from other people's perspectives—to be an "other whisperer" so I don't come across like an arrogant ass.

Anyone for the closing prayer?
Listener Outro & Credits

Bob: Hi, my name is Bob, and I live in West Jordan, Utah. I like to listen to Infants on Thrones as I take long walks around my neighborhood. You can comment on this episode on the website, infantsonthrones.com. And if you really like what you hear, give the quorum a five-star rating and write a short review on iTunes. I did. Anyone for the closing prayer?

Voiceover: Thank you for listening to Infants on Thrones.
Post-Episode Announcement

Glenn Ostlund: Welcome back to Infants on Thrones. I'm Glenn Ostlund.

And just real quick: I started this podcast back in 2012 with several friends who were all in the process of leaving the Mormon church. Back then, I didn't fully understand the mental, emotional, and physiological impact of all this faith crisis stuff. But the more I learned about mental health and the human nervous system, the more I began to understand how deep it actually goes. And it made me want to do more than just podcast.

I became a certified life coach in 2019 and a licensed therapist in 2025. I'm currently building my caseload, and I'm accepting new clients. So, if you or someone you know is seeking either coaching or therapy services, please reach out. I offer a free 15-minute consultation. I'll include a link to my Psychology Today profile on the website and in the show notes.

So, thanks again for listening, and now here's your episode.

Ep 104 – The Placebo Effect – Part 1
Broadcast by